UBI gives people the flexibility to redefine their relationship to work and lead dignified, fulfilling lives without having to “earn a living.”
Olivia Hanks 18. Green New Deal political strategist and organizer, former editor, political researcher, and contributor to The Norwich Radical, 2018. “What we talk about when we talk about work”, It’s Basic Income, edited by Amy Downes and Stewart Lansley, p. 77-80.
Most of us define ourselves by our paid work. It’s what we spend more time doing than anything else. And the rest of our time is often defined by work: travelling to it, recovering from it, or lapsing into total lethargy during holidays as a reaction to it. Yet a 2013 Gallup poll of 142 countries showed that only 13% of people feel engaged by their jobs.14 This source of unhappiness and waste of human potential has led some to argue that the ideal would be to abolish work.15 This may be taking things a little far, even if we take ‘work’ to mean only ‘paid employment’ – I wouldn’t like to abolish doctors, for instance. Nevertheless, it gets us thinking about what work really is. Until the industrial revolution, most people were subsistence farmers, working to produce what they needed and no more. Work as a transaction – time in exchange for money – only became widespread with industrialisation and the mass movement of people into the cities in the 19th century. There, people had no access to land to provide their food, so were forced to ‘earn their living’ in factories, gaining only a fraction of the fruits of their labour as reward. Though working conditions in the UK have improved dramatically, this state of affairs remains fundamentally the same for employees today. The idea that your ‘living’ is something you have to ‘earn’ persists, for the most part quite unchallenged. Yet many people would freely admit that they see their job as essentially pointless. Phrases like ‘earning a living’ and, more recently, ‘hardworking families’ or the rhetorical division of citizens into ‘strivers’ and ‘skivers’ reinforce the view that paid employment is a virtue, and the more hours of it you do, the better. Other useful or fulfilling types of work such as caring and community work are disregarded. The anthropologist David Graeber writes in a 2013 essay that ‘bullshit jobs’ have been created because ‘the feeling that work is a moral value in itself, and that anyone not willing to submit themselves to some kind of intense work discipline for most of their waking hours deserves nothing, is extraordinarily convenient’ for the ruling class.16 This is almost an exact echo of the opening of William Morris’s 1884 lecture ‘Useful Work Versus Useless Toil’: ‘Most people, well-to-do or not, believe that, even when a man is doing work which appears to be useless, he is earning his livelihood by it – he is “employed,” ; and most of those who are well-to-do cheer on the happy worker with praises, if he is only “industrious” enough and deprives himself of all pleasure and holidays in the sacred cause of labour. In short, it has become an article of the creed of modern morality that all labour is good in itself – a convenient belief to those who live on the labour of others.’17 Graeber’s repetition of these thoughts well over a century later, despite the advances in productivity during that time, shows that this is not a question that will ever be solved by more technology or ever-greater productivity – it is clearly a political matter. Much has been written about the impact on jobs of the new wave of automation. Yet despite the widespread concern about the impact on employment, previous waves of automation have not led to a hike in unemployment. Instead, directly productive jobs now done by machines have been replaced by Graeber’s ‘bullshit jobs’ in the clerical, sales and service sectors. Unless we change the way we think about work, we will simply end up with a new generation of meaningless jobs to replace those lost; another generation of workers stuck in jobs they do not like and of which they do not see the point. If we see unemployment as the problem, as artificial intelligence renders vast numbers of jobs obsolete, we risk seeing the creation of a new wave of ‘bullshit jobs’ as the solution. Instead, we should seize upon the growth of artificial intelligence (AI) as the ideal opportunity to introduce a universal basic income, alongside a more progressive system of taxation. A guaranteed, subsistence-level income would end extreme poverty and allow people time to look for meaningful work instead of relying on jobs that are short-term, insecure and exploitative. Recognising that material wealth comes from the earth’s resources and belongs to society as a whole, it would more fairly distribute the wealth created by technological advances, rather than concentrating that wealth in fewer and fewer hands. When we no longer see paid work as an immediate necessity for survival, other reasons for working will come to the fore: intellectual challenge or physical fitness, social interaction, the sense of doing something useful. Once the financial imperative to accept poor pay and conditions has vanished, workers will start demanding that their jobs fulfil some of these other needs. UBI would also give people more choice about how much they work. The result would be better health, both physical and mental; better family life, as parents are no longer forced by financial necessity and social pressure to go back to work at the earliest possible opportunity; and more engagement with politics and community life. Paid employment would no longer be the only or principal determiner of people’s identity, status and self-esteem. One of the most common arguments against UBI is that large numbers of people would give up work. This rests on two assumptions: first, that most people only work for the money, and would stop working if they could; second, that people leaving the workforce would be a terrible thing. The first is unlikely to be the case: most people want to work in some form. Insofar as people do work ‘only for the money’ because they have meaningless, unfulfilling jobs, the greater bargaining power would make employers offer more appealing jobs, whether through improved pay or other means. And while UBI would be sufficient for survival, it would not pay for a life of material comfort. Those who wanted more would still need to be part of the paid workforce. Given that there are always concerns about a shortage of jobs, it cannot logically be argued that some people withdrawing from the workforce would cause society to collapse. Rather, the second assumption is based principally on the belief that everyone has a moral duty to ‘pay their way’ financially, and that any other system is unfair. This is a symptom of the tendency of modern political discourse to place the economy above all else; to refer to it as though society existed to serve its needs, and not the other way round. UBI implicitly recognises a fundamental point: that paid work has no intrinsic value, and that not all valuable work is paid. Many people contribute in other ways, as carers, as artists or as volunteers; some people are simply unable to work full time, and UBI would enable those people to live dignified, meaningful lives.