Every historical attempt at socialism has failed. The romanticized alt depends on shifting the goalposts on what counts as “real” socialism.
Kristian Niemietz 19. PhD in Political Economy from King’s College London and Institute of Economic Affairs’ Head of Political Economy, 2019. Socialism: The Failed Idea That Never Dies, Institute of Economic Affairs, p. 293-296.
And yet, that support for socialism as an ideal is not matched by a positive view of any particular example, contemporary or historical, of socialism in action. On the contrary: whenever any such example is mentioned, socialists invariably roll their eyes and dismiss it as a lazy straw man. Socialists have largely succeeded in distancing them-selves from previous attempts to build socialist socie- ties. Holding a real-world example of socialism against a self-described socialist is considered a cheap shot today. The conventional wisdom is that people who associate socialism with the Warsaw Pact countries, Maoist China, North Korea or North Vietnam are simply not clever enough to understand the difference between an idea and a distorted application. Holding the Gulags or the Berlin Wall against democratic socialists is considered just as boorish as holding the atrocities of Al Qaida or the Islamic State against peaceful Muslims. And yet, when asked what exactly was ‘unreal’ about previous variants of socialism, or what they would have done differently, contemporary socialists struggle to come up with a clear answer. When pressed, they escape into the abstract, talking about lofty aspirations rather than tangible characteristics. But the lofty aspirations that are usually cited are exactly the same old aspirations that have always been the aspirations of socialism. The idea that a socialist system should empower ordinary working people, rather than party apparatchiks, is not remotely as original as contemporary socialists think it is. That has always been the idea. Contemporary socialists define ‘real’ socialism in terms of the outcomes they would like to see, rather than the institutional setup which is supposed to produce those outcomes. By mixing a desired outcome of a system into the very definition of that system, the idea that ‘real’ socialism has never been tried becomes unfalsifiable. It is as if we defined a rain dance as ‘a dance that causes rainfall’, as opposed to ‘a dance that aims to cause rainfall’. Under the latter definition, it is possible to conclude, after a sufficiently large number of failed attempts, that rain dances cannot, after all, cause rain. Under the former definition, that is not possible. If an attempt at a rain dance does not cause rain, then by definition, it cannot have been a real rain dance. A real rain dance has never been tried. Those who claim that rain dances have ‘failed’ are just not clever enough to understand the difference between the idea of a rain dance and a distorted application. Socialism in the sense in which self-identified democratic socialists define it, namely, a democratised economy planned collectively by ‘the people’, has never been achieved anywhere, and could not be achieved. Economic planning can only ever be done in a technocratic, elitist fashion, and it requires an extreme concentration of power in the hands of the state. It cannot ‘empower’ ordinary workers. It can only ever empower a bureaucratic elite. But while this vision of socialism cannot be attained, it can be easily projected onto actually existing societies, by virtue of being so abstract and nebulous. For the same reason, that projection can just as easily be ended. This is what Western intellectuals have been doing for almost a century. Thirty years ago, Hayek (1988) wrote about ‘intellectuals’ vain search for a truly socialist community, which results in the idealisation of, and then disillusionment with, a seemingly endless string of “utopias”’. Since then, this string has only grown longer. The reception of socialist experiments usually follows a three-stage pattern. Socialist experiments often go through an initial honeymoon period, during which they have, or at least seem to have, some initial successes, and during which their international standing is relatively high. During this honeymoon period, the experiment is usually showered with enthusiastic praise from Western intellectuals. It is held up as a role model of ‘true’ socialism, as ‘proof’ that socialism does work, and as an inspiring alternative to the morally bankrupt capitalist systems of the West. This honeymoon never lasts forever. At some point, the model’s failures become more widely known in the West, and the respective country’s international standing de- teriorates. During this period, Western intellectuals look frantically for excuses. There is still widespread support for the model in question, but language and emphasis change drastically: a hopeful and optimistic case is replaced by an angry and defensive one. Western socialists shoot the messenger; they act as if the critics of the system were some- how responsible for the system’s failure. Outside forces and/or members of the old, discredited elites are accused of ‘undermining’ socialism. Western apologists engage extensively in whataboutery, raising counteraccusations and trying to shift attention to unrelated issues. But there comes a point when the system’s failures become so obvious, and its international reputation becomes so irreparably damaged, that defending it becomes a lost cause. This is the third and final stage. Small sects of true believers continue to defend the system, but mainstream intellectuals fall silent on the issue. After a while, the pilgrimages and eulogies fade from memory and Western intellectuals begin to dispute the system’s socialist credentials. The new narrative becomes that the system was never truly socialist, that only a handful of extremists ever claimed it was, and that only a complete ignoramus would hold it against a self-described socialist. This narrative then becomes the conventional wisdom. The reputation of socialism, as an idea, survives unblemished.