Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Marxism relies on an incoherent and contradictory analysis of historical change that doesn’t provide a realistic path to socialism/communism.

Sebastiano Maffettone 21. Full Professor of Political Philosophy at Luiss Guido Carli University of Rome, 2021. Marx in the 21st Century, p. 84-87.

A reconstruction of Marx’s historical materialism is a difficult and arduous task. The first reason for this is that Marx—despite the primary importance of the concept—never presents a unified theory of historical materialism in his writings. The second reason—probably at the root of the first—is that he does not seem to have a unitary and coherent vision of historical materialism itself. The first reason results from the fact that we must use at least four (sections of) different works to get a complete idea of it, an idea that in any case originates with the critique of Hegel in his early years. In the Manifesto Marx limits himself to presenting, in the first part of the work, history from the perspective of historical materialism as the history of the class struggle. In the preface to Critique of Political Economy there is the reconstruction of history in terms of the development of productive forces, and finally, in Capital and in the Grundrisse, history is presented in light of the systematic search for surplus value on the part of the dominant classes. Needless to say that these different versions are not always consistent with each other. More generally, as we said, Marx does not seem to have a unitary and coherent vision of historical materialism. For him, on the one hand, it consists of a theory of the structure of the modes of production, and on the other hand, in a reconstruction of their historical succession. The structural approach summarizes what the different modes of production have in common: a nucleus of productive forces (for example the technology used) and of production relations (based primarily on property) with a superstructure that includes the law, ethics and the culture of every society in general. The historical reconstruction instead presents what the different modes of production do not have in common, so that we can distinguish an Asiatic mode of production, one based on slavery, one on feudal servitude, up to the capitalist mode production. Here again, one cannot say that coherence is Marx’s strong suit in providing a reasonably uniform depiction of the question. This is made even more complicated by the fact that Marx has a generally ambiguous view of history (as we have already seen in the case of exploitation). Here, the ambiguity consists in coexistence, within his thinking of two different conceptions of history: a philosophical history of Hegelian ilk, and an empirical theory of history. The first offers an interpretation of events in light of their contribution to the realization of the end of history. The end of history for Marx is communism, and the philosophy of history that justifies its progressive advent is remarkably similar to a religious vision that foresees the final salvation of humanity. The second offers a set of socio-economic generalizations about social change. Without a doubt, Marx’s philosophy of history is now widely discredited, and few are willing to believe that the history of humanity is a kind of long wait for the advent of communism, but the problem is even more serious, if we consider that Marx’s empirical theory of history is strongly influenced by his philosophy of history (this type of objection, moreover, is at the heart of Benedetto Croce’s criticism of Marx). This confusion between two levels is clearly seen in what is perhaps the main defect of Marx’s whole vision, the underlying determinism. Determinism here means that in history there is an iron law that determines what will happen given what has already happened and in general that the laws of history are the equivalent of the laws of nature, an affinity for which Marx felt along with Darwin (Engels recalled the centrality of historical necessity in Marx’s thought in his speech at Marx’s funeral). Something like this, besides being completely unlikely, would take away from history what is perhaps its essential characteristic, that is, a relative unpredictability. Moreover, what is even worse, a vision of this type deprives human motives and reasons of all meaning and value. Given that determinism tells us where we are going, why should we work hard to realize the end of history? In short, Marxian determinism inevitably condemns us to a life of messianic expectation in which our efforts to understand and act on what we understand are superfluous. Furthermore, it is not easy to understand how Marx was a determinist, in the sense that humans are simply the object of a historical process that passes over their heads, but how much space is left for human choices and decisions. Among other things, it is not easy to understand how deterministic Marx was, in the sense that humans are simply the object of a historical process passing over their heads, and how much room there was for human choices and decisions. The determinism of Marx, if there is any, is still sophisticated. The basic thesis is that within each mode of production there is a dialectic between productive forces and production relations, or if you will between technology and legal regulation of ownership. This relationship is progressively realized until reaching a level of optimality. After this however, this fortunate correspondence degenerates sooner or later into contradiction and over time the production relations become incompatible with the productive forces. The contradiction is generated by the development of new productive forces that render existing production relations obsolete. At this point the necessity arises for “an era of social revolution” destined to remove the contradiction by bringing out new relations of production. It should be noted that this view is, if taken into consideration from a historical point of view, bizarre if not perverse. Take, for example, the necessary transition from capitalism to communism, which is what most interested Marx. His thesis tells us that the technological and productive progress of capitalism should, so to speak, make it rupture in the moment of its greatest development. To imagine something like this is very strange: people turn violent when things go wrong, not when development reaches its maximum! An impression of this kind seems to have been amply confirmed by history, as communist revolutions took place in countries that were on average backward in terms of the development of productive forces. Another weak point, in this perspective, concerns the absolute uncertainty that surrounds Marx’s communism when we consider it from the point of view of the balance between productive forces and relations of production. Once again in this case the Hegelian dialectic and Hegel’s philosophy of history seem to replace the arguments in favor of Marx’s thesis in this regard. We, in other words, can bet on communism only if we imagine it as an imminent end of history through a general dialectic which sees history go from primitive communism to capitalist alienation, which is then in turn removed by the final conquest of saving communism. But this is a quasi-religious vision that seems to have little to do with the desired balance between new modes of production and social relationships that can bring them to power. What has been said in the last paragraph shows how Marx, to reach the revolution, does not focus so much on an argument in favor of communism as on an argument against capitalism. Capitalism, in his opinion, is condemned to failure according to its own principles, and sooner or later it will fail to provide the material goods on which it had founded its hope of success. Although it is strange to imagine the two together, Marx often seems to think that capitalism will simultaneously lead to an extreme impoverishment of the working class and to the end of capitalist profit.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.