Modern capitalism is not a destructive monolith. Attributing all current issues to capitalism ignores real-world developments that can’t be explained by Marxist analysis.
David Lane 20. Fellow of the Academy of Social Sciences (UK) and Emeritus Fellow of Emmanuel College, Cambridge University, 3-18-2020. “Building socialism: from ‘scientific’ to ‘active’ Marxism”, Third World Quarterly, vol. 41(8) p. 1306-1321.
All the countries of the world have been drawn into the capitalist order; capitalism has continued to grow and spread, and its developments have confounded Marx’s predictions. Its contradictions have been resolved, at least partially, through forms of coordination and control exercised by the state and increasingly by regional and global institutions. The polarisation of class struggle, anticipated by Marx, has been occluded by a much more differentiated occupational system promoting a pluralistic and socially diverse political process. Capitalism has moved from chaotic competition to a more organised form constituted by global financial and non-financial companies and transnational institutions. The cyclical development of capitalism continues. World capitalism has shown a capability for diffusion and adaptation. It is conditioned by variations which exist in different economic and political formations. ‘Scientific Marxism’, like ‘Darwinism’ in the physical world, is subject to revision in the light of new facts and theories. Marx’s materialist approach has been widely accepted, while many of his political predictions have been discarded. In this respect his work has been absorbed to various degrees by different subjects in the humanities and social sciences; it has influenced political parties and legitimated political leaders; and it remains a fertile but debatable approach to our understanding of world history. Marx made a significant contribution to the understanding of the nineteenth-century class structure of capitalism. His knowledge is limited to the society he knew at the time. To overcome the tendency to reductionism, Marx’s approach might be developed with insights from other theories and approaches. Bureaucracy, patriarchy, militarism and credentialism (the exercise of ‘expert’ knowledge) also constitute forms of political and economic power and have their own laws of development. Social discrimination and political domination should be distinguished from economic exploitation. Such forms of power sometimes overlap with the interests of economic classes, but they are primarily performed by social groups and elites sometimes operating on behalf of nation states or international organisations. It is mistaken to attribute all the malformations, inadequacies and injustices to inherent faults or contradictions in the class structures of capitalist or socialist regimes. Other problems, such as those concerned with environmental exploitation as well as the consequences of nuclear war, have assumed greater importance in the twenty-first century and were not anticipated by Marx’s historical materialism. To understand current international conflict, Thucydides provides a geo-strategic dimension unheeded by Marx. The oppression of marginalised groups has cultural and historical roots. Cultural values are deeply engrained and prove obstinate to change. These dimensions of power might be shaped by, but are not constituent parts of, economic exploitation and should be analysed separately. Moreover, they cannot be equated with economic exploitation – Marx has been vindicated in giving to the ownership of private property and economic surplus obtained through market relationships a qualitatively different level of power than other forms of domination and discrimination.