3---UBI doesn’t solve trust or democracy
Daron Acemoglu 19. Institute Professor of Economics in the Department of Economics at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, 6-19-2019. "Why Universal Basic Income is a bad idea," https://www.marketwatch.com/story/why-universal-basic-income-is-a-bad-idea-2019-06-19.
Equally important, these solutions leverage democratic politics. The same cannot be said for a UBI, which is parachuted from above as a way of placating the discontented masses.
It neither empowers nor even consults the people it aims to help. (Do workers who have lost their middle-class jobs want government transfers or an opportunity to get another job?) As such, UBI proposals have all the hallmarks of the “bread and circuses” used by the Roman and Byzantine Empires — handouts to defuse discontent and mollify the masses, rather than providing them with economic opportunities and political agency.
By contrast, the modern social welfare state that has served developed countries so well was not handed down by tycoons and politicians. It aimed to provide both social insurance and opportunities to people.
And it was the result of democratic politics. Ordinary people made demands, complained, protested, and got involved in policy making, and the political system responded.
The founding document of the British welfare state, the World War II-era Beveridge Report, was as much a response to political demands as to economic hardship. It sought to protect the disadvantaged and create opportunities, while encouraging civic engagement.
Many current social problems are rooted in our neglect of the democratic process. The solution isn’t to dribble out enough crumbs to keep people at home, distracted, and otherwise pacified.