UBI’s ineffective at generating trust in government---the impacts on workers are negative
Anna Coote 19. Principal Fellow at the New Economics Foundation, and Edanur Yazici, April 2019. “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME A UNION PERSPECTIVE.” http://www.world-psi.org/sites/default/files/documents/research/en_ubi_full_report_2019.pdf
There are strong arguments against UBI. It is thought to have negative im- pacts on workers and to cost too much, absorbing funds that would be better spent in other ways. It diverts political energies from more important issues and shores up neoliberal ideology.
IMPACTS ON LABOUR
Trade union critics note the danger of UBI entrenching low pay and pre- carious work. It could effectively subsidise employers who pay low wages and – by creating a small cushion for workers on short-term and zero-hours contracts - help to normalise precarity. The German Trade Union Federation, the DGB, has said of UBI: “It’s no solution to shunt somebody aside with a standstill reward just because people cannot be offered any decent jobs an- ymore... [it’s] a complete disorientation”25. In the face of a rapidly changing labour market, the DGB has called for greater funds to be invested in quality public services26.