UBI worsens work incentives---economic modeling
John F. Cogan 21. Leonard and Shirley Ely Senior Fellow, Hoover Institution, with Daniel L. Heil, 1-14-21. “The Economic Impact of a Universal Basic Income.” https://www.hoover.org/sites/default/files/research/docs/prosperityproject_cogan_heil.pdf
UBI supporters acknowledge this departure and counter that a UBI will improve work incentives and redistribute income to achieve a more equitable income distribution. Our economic analysis has cast serious doubt on these claims. While a UBI can improve work incentives among recipients of the transfer programs it replaces, a UBI worsens work incentives among UBI recipients who are not beneficiaries of these programs. In our analysis of a UBI that has no phase- down provision, aggregate labor supply increases slightly. But such a plan dramatically worsens the distribution of income by redistributing government transfer payments from lower- to higher-income households. In our analysis of UBI plans that have phase-down provisions, work incentives are reduced and, as a result, these plans would all significantly reduce aggregate US labor supply and, thereby, US economic output. These plans show little improvement in the distribution of income.