3. UBI either costs too much or is inadequate to solve.
Anna Coote 19. Principal Fellow at the New Economics Foundation, and Edanur Yazici, April 2019. “UNIVERSAL BASIC INCOME A UNION PERSPECTIVE.” http://www.world-psi.org/sites/default/files/documents/research/en_ubi_full_report_2019.pdf
Some of the most trenchant criticisms of UBI focus on its costs and afforda- bility. The higher the level of payment, the greater the amount of additional funds needed to pay for it – and vice versa. This is neatly summed up by Martinelli who concludes from his own microsimulations (see above): “an af- fordable UBI is inadequate and an adequate UBI is unaffordable”.
There are inevitably winners and losers and the effects are not necessarily progressive. If means-tested benefits are abolished to help pay for UBI, then some of the most vulnerable people on low incomes are bound to suffer. If income taxes are raised across the board, workers on low pay are likely to lose out. In one scheme modelled by Martinelli, both child and working age poverty fell by around 14-15% and the Gini coefficient by 5.5%, yet there were still “unacceptably high proportions of households losing out amongst lower income deciles”27.
David Piachaud, leading expert on social security, is highly critical of the claim made for basic income that he calls the “justice of unconditionality” and ar- gues that “a targeted social security system was, is and always will be more efficient and equitable than a full Basic Income”28.