Restructuring the federal tax code is essential.
Naomi Zewde et al., 21. Assistant Professor in the Graduate School of Public Health and Health Policy at the City University of New York, with Kyle Strickland, Kelly Capatosto, Ari Glogower, and Darrick Hamilton, May 2021. “a guaranteed income for the 21st century.” https://kirwaninstitute.osu.edu/sites/default/files/Guaranteed%20Income%20for%20the%2021st%20Century.pdf
Current tax and fiscal policies fall far short of fostering economic inclusion, social equity, and civic engagement to all households. To the contrary, many of the most important structural features of our tax code privilege those with existing wealth, instead of creating new pathways for wealth-building opportunities for lower- and middle- income families.
Decline of Progressive Taxation
Under a progressive tax system, taxpayers with greater ability to pay contribute proportionally more of their income. In recent decades, however, federal taxes have become less progressive. Many important structural features of the current tax system now disproportionately benefit the wealthiest taxpayers. For example, rules such as capital income preference, which taxes certain forms of investment income at lower rates than labor income; and the realization rule, which allows investors to defer taxes until they sell their investments, deliver large tax benefits and avoidance opportunities to the highest earners (Glogower, 2016; Marr et al., 2019). Researchers at the Tax Policy Center estimate that the top 1 percent of earners alone capture more than 60 percent of the benefit from the lower rate at which capital income is taxed (Berger & Toder, 2019).
In prior periods of tax reform, the wealthy benefited from large tax cuts under the administrations of Presidents Ronald Reagan and George W. Bush. Recent tax changes have piled new tax benefits on the wealthy, and further undermined the progressivity of the tax system. The 2017 tax legislation (often referred to as the Trump Tax Plan) cut the tax rates on corporations and high-income taxpayers, doubled the estate tax exemption amount, introduced a new deduction for income earned through “pass-through businesses,” and opened up new tax planning opportunities for sophisticated taxpayers (Gamage & Kamin, 2019). The Tax Policy Center estimated at the time that taxpayers in the bottom income quintile would receive an average tax cut of $60 (0.4 percent of their after-tax income) from the changes in the 2017 legislation, while the top 1 percent of earners would receive an average tax cut of $51,000 (3.4 percent of their after-tax income) (Tax Policy Center Staff, 2017).
Even recent tax reforms designed to provide economic relief from the coronavirus and economic shutdowns delivered the greatest benefits to the wealthiest taxpayers. The CARES Act included windfall provisions for big businesses—in the form of loss and interest expense deductions—that have been described as “shoveling money to rich people.” (Drucker, 2020; Wallace, 2020).
These changes have accelerated the decline of the progressive tax system. Economists Emmanuel Saez and Gabriel Zucman find that the cumulative decline in the three critical elements of the progressive tax system—the individual income tax, the corporate tax, and the estate tax—have brought the overall tax system closer to a “flat tax” where taxpayers with lower income now pay tax at comparable rates to the highest income taxpayers (Saez & Zucman, 2019a; Saez & Zucman, 2019b).4 Further, progressive aspects of the federal tax code are often offset by regressive state and local taxes (Huang & Taylor, 2019). These regressive rules, including flat consumption taxes from which individuals and families with lower incomes pay a larger share of their income, further compound racial disparities in after-tax income and wealth.
Racial and Gender Effects
The federal tax code is ostensibly race neutral and determines tax liabilities based on factors such as total income, sources of income, and savings (Huang & Taylor, 2019). At the same time, structural and outright bias affects many race-neutral areas of law, including tax law (Kendi, 2019).
To be sure, some federal tax provisions, such as the EITC and the Child Tax Credit (CTC), do reduce some racial disparities by raising the after-tax incomes of families employed in low-paying jobs (Huang and Taylor, 2019). Many other critical features of the tax system, however, disproportionately benefit White Americans. For example, White households not only earn higher incomes than Black and Latinx households, but a greater amount of their wealth is generated from non-labor assets, such as mutual funds and stocks, that are treated favorably in the tax code in the form of lower tax rates (Hamilton et al., 2020). Each year, the federal government spends over $630 billion on asset-building tax programs like savings, retirement accounts, and homeownership – support that helps build wealth for largely wealthy and disproportionately White households (Nieves et al., 2020).