UBI stabilizes social inequality
Giuseppe Allegri 21. Independent and freelancer researcher, consultant, teacher and trainer in Public and Constitutional Law, Ph. D. in Theory of the State, with Renato Foschi, “Universal Basic Income as a Promoter of Real Freedom in a Digital Future.” World Futures: The Journal of New Paradigm Research, Volume 77, 2021 - Issue 1. Taylor & Francis.
By now, the UBI has become a theme in mainstream American political science journals and has attracted the interest of researchers of the millennial generation. It is considered a protective factor in the case of job insecurity and unemployment, a stabilizer of social inequality, and a promoter of the freedom of the worker to defend himself from the monotonous, weary, or underpaid gigs in the digitized economy. These factors seem to be increasing rather than decreasing in the technological and digitized society, especially because present and future automation seems destined to totally replace certain professional figures, distribution of goods or some specific, highly specialized work tasks (Bidadanure, Citation2019). The use of artificial intelligence therefore seems to determine a decrease in the working hours necessary for production, which has as a consequence an impoverishment of the working middle class. In the coming years, this situation will lead to a labor market that will need personnel to perform AI-related tasks or that will involve creative and relational skills that are difficult to reproduce by means of AI (Ernst et al., Citation2019).
These new scenarios challenge the Protestant work ethic based on positive or negative individuals; the former builds their own destinies; the latter are idle and unproductive, undeserving of success. Giving all individuals a universal income is totally contrary to these assumptions. It is therefore heresy with respect to Protestant ethics.
Social conditions and the market in the digital age, however, are actually changing the scenario: Social inequality is increasing because work has profoundly changed, tends to decrease and to be unstable, and people are not paid what they are worth. The historically disadvantaged classes such as immigrants, black people, and women in this situation are in a sort of Procrustean bed that marginalizes them more and more. Protestant ethics are therefore no longer a rational justification for a situation that is characterized by polarization between rich and poor, people and oligarchies. Nozick’s classic analysis (Citation1974/1999, pp. 169–172) of distributive justice concerning forced labor and taxation as conditions profoundly contrary to individual freedom cannot “logically” be sustained in the context of the epochal changes we are witnessing. According to Nozick, the worker had to be able to freely enjoy the fruits of his work, and state taxation was considered an anti-liberal constraint that took away freedom and free time. However, the digital society, on the one hand, frees up resources and knowledge, and on the other, imposes constraints. It not only leads to the transformation of work but also to a kind of new exploitation of leisure time that hides new forms of unpaid work.
Above all, millennials are not only the users of the new tools provided by communication and digital companies but also the unsuspecting workers for these companies: testers of mobile phones, computers, operating systems, apps, etc., that are tested directly in the market. In the new digitized society, where the interests of companies and employers are more important than redistributive activities, leisure time is secretly exploited by turning consumers into workers who simultaneously test, use, consume, and are unwittingly hired as workers by the digitized communication system to which they provide online feedback on how they use electronic devices, how they communicate, their tastes and political choices, where they are, and what they do. Ubi can therefore also be seen as a form of remuneration for “implicit digital work” that helps artificial intelligence companies to make profits by “implicitly” using the consumer’s free time (Marturano & Vizmuller-Zocco, Citation2019).
Regarding basic income in the present and future digital society, there is therefore the need to guarantee Ius Existentiae, a dignified and free life, within the accelerated transformations of technological innovation. Therefore, it is argued that basic income, in the desirable evolutionary path from guaranteed minimum income to universal and unconditional basic income, should not be understood only as a necessary and fundamental “fight against poverty” by public institutions but as a trigger for processes of individual self-determination and promotion of a new idea of society: one that can hold together emancipation and solidarity, autonomy and cooperation, in the sense of guaranteeing the widest possible freedom of choice in one’s work for a better management of time, social relations, and to fight against the domination of one social group over others (for two complementary futuristic conceptions of the UBI see Bregman, Citation2017; Srnicek & Williams, Citation2015).
Basic income must therefore be thought of as a fundamental social right to existence and a suitable measure for the protection of the dignity and self-determination of the human being at a time when the multiplication and social and global division of the workforce open up daily horizons of workers on the digital platforms of the new capitalism. There is a reduction of traditional forms of employment in the progressive automation of many trades and working environments in an era characterized by the unemployment of masses of migrants from the south of the world in search of a decent life but becoming Cyber-proletariat (Dyer-Whiteford, Citation2015) with more progressive proletarianization not only of the traditional salaried dependent workers but also of the self-employed and independent workers (Stiegler, Citation2016). Therefore, basic income is also to be understood as a social dividend of the digital era, which allows access to the redistribution of wealth collectively produced on the Internet, thanks to the social cooperation among many consumers but still confined among the monopolists who own digital enterprises and the Web. UBI, considered as a social dividend, could therefore not only be a promoter of psychological well-being and a protective factor against stress and workplace mobbing, but above all as a lever that returns free time to be reinvested in creative, educational, and relational activities useful for the improvement of the digitized society that is based on innovation and creativity.
Basic income is therefore to be understood as a new institution and a trigger of public policies of social transformation. It is able to enhance the progressive developments offered by technological and digital innovations in order to collectively imagine and realize a new welfare society in which it is possible to protect and promote health and education, inclusive rethinking of cities, housing, and mobility, and the global spread of post-national solidarity between material and immaterial networks. Basic income allows rethinking the systems of production and distribution of value and wealth from human beings, with the help of machines, in a process in favor of human beings and the living environment:
Guaranteed income will be fundamental to rethink the system of value production and wealth creation that is increasingly collective and social, while profits are increasingly private and concentrated. A guaranteed income will make it possible to carry out creative work instead of those routine and repetitive jobs that will in any case be replaced by robots and artificial intelligence. We therefore need a guaranteed income as a dividend paid by the better productivity of robots returning to society, responsible for having collectively produced that wealth. (Bria, Citation2017, p. 62)
In short, the UBI represents a space for immediate intervention, on the present to plan the future, with the prospect of introducing a social security instrument that tries to design another idea of society, in which the human capacity to invent artifices, tools, mechanisms to reduce fatigue, increase social wealth and its consequent redistribution, saving working time under repetitive commands, for a fully automated post-capitalism, can be brought to its rosiest conclusions:
The ambition here is to take back the future from capitalism and build ourselves the twenty-first-century world we want. It is to provide the time and money that are central to any meaningful conception of freedom. (Srnicek & Williams, Citation2015, p. 64)
Maybe the basic income can definitively guarantee a real freedom for all.