Doesn’t solve inequality---state tax regimes are inherently regressive. That triggers our populism impact.
Samuel D. Brunson, 22. Georgia Reithal Professor of Law, Loyola University Chicago School of Law, summer 2022. “Bargain Basement Progressivity? Constitutional Flat Taxes, Demogrants, and Progressive Income Taxation,” 53 Loy. U. Chi. L. J. 683 (2022). https://lawecommons.luc.edu/luclj/vol53/iss4/3
State and local tax regimes, which rely largely on regressive forms of taxation, unsurprisingly tend to be regressive themselves. That regressiv- ity means that poorer and minoritized state residents tend to pay more as a percentage of their income for state services than higher-income resi- dents. And if they and high-income residents do not pay enough, they are left with reduced services, a burden that also falls harder on the poor than on the rich.
To the extent that states ameliorate this regressivity, they tend to do so through the imposition of a progressive income tax. But even among the majority of states that have a personal income tax, that tax does little to affect the overall mix of regressive taxes. Most states with progressive income taxes have limited progressivity in their income taxes, and that limited progressivity does little to deal with income inequality or the state’s other regressive taxes.234