Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Only the federal government can revise the taxation scheme---automation is cross-border which requires federal law to enforce taxes extraterritorially – the CP would either not enforce taxes or get struck down

Hayes R. Holderness, 17. Visiting Assistant Professor of Law, University of Illinois College of Law, “Taking Tax Due Process Seriously: The Give and Take of State Taxation,” Richmond School of Law, 2017, https://scholarship.richmond.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2434&context=law-faculty-publications

Given the above analysis, the states' current efforts to remove Quill's physical presence rule for sales and use taxes and to adopt economic nexus standards for other taxes will not grant the states enforcement jurisdiction over all remote vendors making sales to their residents. Under the something-forwhich-it-can-ask-return aspect of the due process nexus inquiry, there is a set of remote vendors over which the states do not have enforcement jurisdiction: those whose only connection to a state is selling to residents of that state that approach the vendors with orders. If history has any lesson here, it is that people will model their practices in order to avoid a state's jurisdiction to tax if possible and efficient for them.' Once the dominance of the Commerce Clause limitations on enforcement jurisdiction is undermined, people should be expected to change their behavior in response to the Due Process Clause limitations. As the states' current issues with remote vendors demonstrate, these limitations can have a serious economic impact. 154 The potential "jurisdictional misalignment"' arising from a state having substantive jurisdiction over its residents' use of goods sold by a remote vendor but not having enforcement jurisdiction as a practical matter over the residents or as a legal matter over the remote vendor demonstrates the need to redefine the relationship between the federal government and the states with respect to state jurisdiction to tax if the states wish to fully solve their remote vendor issues. As others have argued, limitations on state-level enforcement jurisdiction may indicate the need to impose state tax collection obligations at the federal level."' Understanding the something-for-which-itcan-ask-return aspect confirms the need to think beyond state-level enforcement jurisdiction (barring a judicial refining of the due process limitations on state jurisdiction to tax, which may itself be due 157).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.