State action still links - national party integration ensures feds get drawn in
Jessica Bulman-Pozen, 16. Associate Professor, Columbia Law School, “Executive Federalism Comes to America,” 102 Virginia Law Review 953 (June 2016), Available at: https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/faculty_scholarship/3175
In the United States today, national partisan conflict and cooperation occur in an integrated way across the states and the federal government. In previous work, I have focused on the contestatory aspects of this "partisan federalism" - the ways in which political actors use both the state and federal governments to stage partisan competition. n51 In one recent display of how partisan alliances trump institutional affiliations and national conflict gets played out in state as well as federal sites, Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell sent a letter urging governors to resist the Clean Power Plan promulgated by President Obama's Environmental Protection Agency ("EPA"). n52 The most powerful member of Congress thus tried to enlist the states to fight another part of the federal government on partisan grounds. And he addressed his argument to governors in particular, recognizing that the key players in shaping national policy and the state-federal relationship had become the executives at both levels of government. Importantly, however, partisan federalism creates alliances as well as opposition. The same Clean Power Plan that Senator McConnell opposes also offers an example of state-federal cooperation fueled by shared ideological commitments. n53 The decline of dual federalism underlies this dynamic - the fact that the state and federal governments regulate in the same areas facilitates state-federal cooperation. Indeed, the significance of such partisan connections may be most apparent in traditional cooperative federalism schemes, when states and the federal government are jointly administering a federal program. But these connections also matter in the absence of such programs because state legislation or regulation may be a means of furthering a national agenda frustrated in Washington. Unable to get a minimum wage increase through Congress, for example, President Obama seized on already-underway state efforts and argued to the National Governors Association, among others, that states [*967] could be critical fora for national governance. n54 In 2014 and 2015, several blue states increased the minimum wage, advancing within particular jurisdictions a goal broadly shared among Democratic officials. n55 As the Clean Power Plan and minimum wage examples suggest, national, polarized parties do not generate only federal-state conflict or cooperation. They generate both at the same time. Party identification leads different groups of state and federal actors to ally with each other and against opposing groups of state and federal actors. Even this statement is much too simple. As Parts III and IV of this Article argue, partisan positions become more complicated as state and federal actors interact in a variety of ways. While the most basic and readily apparent dynamic of partisan federalism is that Democrats and Republicans recognize members of their own party as allies - and members of the other party as opponents - across the state-federal divide, diversity exists among officials of the same party, especially when they are able to negotiate on their own instead of aggregating their interests. National parties help to fuel deep federal-state integration, even as a variety of different and shifting relationships emerge from such integration.