Renewables empirically fail – too much space, inefficient, inconsistent, and outpaced by natural gas in every way
Clemente 19 Jude Clemente - I am Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC. I hold a B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis. I got my M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics. “Five Practical Problems For The 'Green New Deal,” Forbes, Apr 29, 2019, https://www.forbes.com/sites/judeclemente/2019/04/29/five-practical-problems-for-the-green-new-deal/?sh=6acfb9f3e8a1 ///Mgal
Spacing Modern wind and solar farms require huge swaths of land. Giant windmills, for instance, get spaced a half-mile apart or more. Since “density is green,” this lowers their “green credentials,” while making compact modern natural gas plants, for instance, more environmentally sound. The 550 MW Topaz Solar Farm in California occupies 4,600 football fields worth of land. In contrast, the state’s 850 MW gas-powered Delta Energy Center takes up about 15 football fields (20 acres). These unintended consequences of renewables can’t be ignored. Harvard study: “Wide-scale US wind power could cause significant warming.” This spacing issue for wind and solar coincides with their underreported “sweet spot problem.” Not all locations have the same prospects for renewables, justifying why wind-deprived southeastern states haven't installed Renewable Portfolio Standards. The Midwest, for instance, is great for wind but building the hundreds of miles of high-voltage power lines to connect distant consuming areas has proven as difficult and costly as it sounds. Ultimately, the number of places to put a big wind and solar farm is finite, which is why the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) actually projects that gas will add nearly 10 times more generation capacity than wind and 34% more than solar additions in the decades ahead. With prospects based on geography, it’s as obvious as you think: wind and solar builds will be forced to flatten out at some point. Intermittency The reality is that wind and solar power are usually only available some 30% of the time, as DOE shows. California’s giant Alta Wind Energy Center, for instance, has an average capacity factor of just 24%, meaning that 76% of the time it is not producing the electricity that it could be. It is typically a peaking natural gas plant that compensates for the intermittency of Mother Nature. In fact, this gas backup is an added practical cost (from both a money and environmental perspective) for wind and solar that usually doesn’t get factored into their cost analysis, making them appear cheaper in studies than reality ultimately proves out. Now we know that storage batteries are advancing to help this intermittency problem for wind and solar, but large-scale batteries have been promised to us for decades. MIT Technology Review puts it bluntly: batteries are “far too expensive to play a major role.” And remember that wind and solar are strictly sources of electricity, meaning that they only compete in ~40% of our total energy demand market.