The Push for renewables is immoral – It neglects the poor in America and abroad who rely on Oil and gas for their energy needs, taking that away would mean mass death, especially in the global South
Clemente 19 Jude Clemente - I am Principal at JTC Energy Research Associates, LLC. I hold a B.A. in International Relations from Penn State University, with a minor in Statistical Analysis. I got my M.S. in Homeland Security from San Diego State University, with a focus on Energy Security, and an MBA from St. Francis University, with a focus on Energy Economics. “Five Practical Problems For The 'Green New Deal,” Forbes, Apr 29, 2019, https://www.forbes.com/sites/judeclemente/2019/04/29/five-practical-problems-for-the-green-new-deal/?sh=6acfb9f3e8a1 ///Mgal
Developing Nations Howard Schultz is right, the Green New Deal is “immoral,” but for more than he offered The most telling part of “the value of fossil fuels” is that they supply over 80% of the energy used in the richest nations on Earth with the healthiest people. It’s statistically proven: those nations using the most fossil fuels are more educated, make more money, and live much longer than those using the least. This can’t be stressed enough: it's the countries that DON’T use many fossil fuels that are the poorest and the least healthy. It never gets mentioned that 6 in every 7 humans alive today live in undeveloped nations, lacking proper access to the reliable and affordable energy needed to growth their economies. The sad unintended consequence of the focus only on climate is that it has made life-shortening “energy poverty” a forgotten calamity. Half of the world or more doesn’t have proper access to electricity, the foundation of a modern society. Nearly 17,300 children die each day from preventable causes, enabled by a lack of energy. Tragically, all of this has now become an afterthought. As opposed to some grand “Koch conspiracy,” there are both cost and physical explanations for why wind and solar account for only 3% of global energy supply. The World Bank, International Energy Agency, and other leaders have stood opposed to the unfairness of blocking fossil fuels from poor nations, which is why they strongly support major investments in carbon capture. Sinking Other Investments Oil and gas supply 60% of the world’s energy, and their ongoing importance is obvious: hundreds of billions of dollars each year are being invested in producing and transporting them. These are some of the leading companies in the world, surely not foolish enough to be investing so heavily in energy development that won’t be needed. Case in point came this past week when Occidental Petroleum’s $57 billion counteroffer to Chevron’s $52 billion bid to buy Anadarko Petroleum. Mutual funds are full of oil and gas companies because they are good investments: “Public pension funds must not divest from reality.” Oil and gas are not stranded but required assets. Our own DOE has them still supplying over half of U.S. energy through at least 2050. Thus, trying to sink investment in domestic supply will only serve the rest of the nation like it has California (reliance on OPEC oil) and New England (reliance on Russian gas). Not to mention the jobs and huge tax revenues provided for states. The U.S. oil and gas business, for instance, supports 10.3 million jobs: “Support Your Local Oil and Natural Gas Company.” Fossil Fuel Inputs It’s truly the ultimate irony of the anti-fossil fuel push. Oil, gas, and coal are so entrenched in our immense energy complex that when you are doing pretty much anything, you are relying on them. To illustrate, petro-chemicals are the building blocks of our clothing, plastics, and thousands of other products that we use every day, ensuring that we will need oil for as far as the eye can see. Even electric cars, which are only selling a few hundred thousand a year (as compared to a U.S. oil-based fleet of 250 million), require lots more gas and coal.