Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The green new deal is a stopgap to keep capitalism on life support- it will rely on private investments and labor relationships that expand the power of capital

John McCollum|Dec 11, 2019

Assistant professor of Sociology, Minot State University; Limits of the Green New Deal; Marxist Sociology Blog; https://marxistsociology.org/2019/12/limits-of-the-green-new-deal/

The GND is consciously modeled on the New Deal of the 1930s. The New Deal saw an expansion of social programs benefiting wide swathes of the working class. Social Security was lifted wholesale from socialist programs. Farm aid encouraged both recovery from environmental problems like the Dust Bowl and debt relief for poor farmers. Infrastructural development raised wages and boosted further growth. In terms of arts and culture, working people were mobilized into new forms of cultural production celebrating working-class identity. The general agitation during this period by the broad left pushed these programs forward despite the opposition of powerful factions of the capitalist class in the United States. Despite this legacy, the New Deal preserved capitalism during one of its most dire crises to date; the GND may perform a similar regulatory function. One of the boosts the GND is likely to give to capital is through state investment through private partnerships. The GND does not propose the creation of state ownership of utilities, much less agriculture, housing, or medical care. Similarly, the bill has provisions for energy upgrades through refurbishing existing buildings, environmental cleanup, and an unusual provision to “ensure businesspersons are free from unfair competition.” Without further establishing state ownership over these sectors, many of these provisions are going to add value to existing private property or rely on contractors to do the work, paid for by large sums of public money. Although the GND provides decent employment and these emission reduction programs are desperately needed, much of this activity will generate further wealth in private hands if not performed by the state. The present electoral left may not be capable of enacting or want to deliver on this revolutionary goal. The Green New Deal could end up following a similar course of initial interest, growth, and collapse. However, a “Green” New Deal has other social and environmental goals which need to be considered. As environmental degradation continues, compromise measures that do not lead to drastic cuts in greenhouse gases, mining and processing of non-renewable energy sources, and losses of biodiversity will not suffice. However, such activities might provide some degree of environmental stability that will enable capital to continue its dominance.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.