Control link—the aff’s attempt to make capitalism greener is just a new form of social control to continue looting the working class and the Global South
Ajl 21
Max, associated researcher with the Tunisian Observatory for Food Sovereignty and the Environment and a postdoctoral fellow with the Rural Sociology Group at Wageningen University. “1 Great Transition – or Fortress Eco-Nationalism?” A People’s Green New Deal. Pp 21-23. LS
Concern about the climate crisis has become overwhelming in the Global North. It is no longer the isolated worry of climate scientists, forward-thinking investors, coastal real estate proprietors, or “environmental” activists. From financiers at Davos to McKinsey Consulting, it is everywhere, as the business press and mainstream media emit blizzards of policy papers, communiques, and financial forecasts.1 Why? In part, climate change is now unmissable. Eighteen-degree Celsius days in January in New England. Catastrophic floods and hellish heatwaves across the US Great Plains and Paris. Climate change is no longer in the future tense. It is today. The media is forced to pay attention as people understand more clearly what is happening and why it is happening. Yet most media outlets are owned by big corporations that are part of the capitalist system responsible for climate change.2 So the speed and simultaneity with which the ruling class has changed its tune, from decades of denialism to widely touted tabulations like that of the World Economic Forum “that $44 trillion of economic value generation…is moderately or highly dependent on nature and its services and is… exposed to nature loss,” ought to make anyone curious.3 For climate change does not dictate any specific political response. This chapter considers the rising chorus for “emergency change” from those with their hands on the pulleys and levers of the machine, in order to understand how top-down plans seek to maintain exclusion and exploitation in the world-system. Not the 1 percent but more like the .01 percent, who have seen incomes and net worth scrape the sky during the neoliberal age. They wish to preserve an imperial way of life and the planetary resource base upon which to live it. Their hands, pens, and plans are not idle. Amidst rising awareness of the capitalism–climate nexus, it is only natural that the ruling class would seek to avert a climate crisis which could imperil their power, to displace blame from fossil capitalism to a faceless and structureless humanity, and to make the poor pay the costs of transition. There is not a whit of concern here for the well-being of the working class, or more than a few grains of worry for non-human life. If that were the case, they would have taken action on climate change 30 years ago. Rather, a constellation of forward-looking right-wing and liberal forces plan for what the global sociologist Philip McMichael calls “managing the future.”4 These range from the Australian Breakthrough Institute – a doppelganger of the Ted Nordhaus think-tank with the same name based in California – the Energy Transitions Commission, and on to figures often associated with the progressive left. Such proposals share a number of leitmotifs: corporate– community and corporate–state/business–state partnerships, warmth to the national security sector, a Promethean enthusiasm for “new tech,” recasting models to integrate variables like climactic risk and enfolding them into investment horizons, and a greened US military. A large number are converging on what the economist Daniela Gabor calls the Wall Street Consensus, reorganizing “development interventions around selling development finance to the market…escort[ing] capital” into bonds, and melting and reforging Third World governments as the “de-risking state,” relegating risks onto states and their treasuries and budgets as sovereign representatives of the people and removing those risks from the mountains of capital which such plans seek to mobilize.5 GREEN SOCIAL CONTROL Green Social Control aims to preserve the essence of capitalism while shifting to a greener model in order to sidestep the worst consequences of the climate crisis. Because there is no capitalism that exists apart from the violent hand of the state, such plans emphasize the national security sector. Drawing borders around the people, denizens, or citizens of the nation means exclusion.6 Structural exclusion, from popular development. Ideological exclusion, from concern or care. Physical exclusion, through hardened steel, concrete, razor-wire and motion-sensor kitted-out borders and militarized maritime zones. And temporal exclusion, in the erasure of a past of colonial looting and atmospheric enclosure. Such plans are engineered by the best and the brightest, and we have to take them at their precise word. What they say or do not say about the Third World is what they mean. And because the US is an empire, sitting astride tremendous flows of energy and capital, silences speak. A decision to avoid reparations is a blueprint for world management in which imperial loot remains in the North. Part of the right’s Great Transition is to match up existing assets such as working-class pensions, or the public resources of the people in the form of the state budget, with new tech to harness and commodify the sun and the wind through solar power and wind energy. Greening the US military is central. Putting prices on “eco-system” services, including a potentially serf-like labor-intensive CO2 drawdown program, is a third pillar of their programs. And because the framework of threat is paramount in securing the consent of the core citizenry to their programs, the alarm bell of emergency blares daily (in this case accurately) to frighten people into accepting any plausible program to preserve a livable Earth.