Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

A basic income for healthcare solves the aff better – more efficient with administration and guaranteed access.

Emanuel and Fuchs ‘07 [Ezekiel J. Emanuel, Department of Bioethics, National Institutes of Health, Victor R. Fuchs, Department of Economics and Department of Health Research and Policy, Stanford University, “A Comprehensive Cure: Universal Health Care Vouchers,” pgs. (15-19), Brookings Institution, 7/1/2007, https://www.brookings.edu/articles/a-comprehensive-cure-universal-health-care-vouchers/]@RN

Table 3 summarizes the principal differences between the proposed universal health care voucher system and proposals for individual mandates and single-payer systems. Unlike individual mandates, universal health care vouchers would simply and efficiently achieve universal coverage without the costly administration of income-based subsidies. The poor and the sick would be implicitly subsidized by the difference between the value of the voucher to them and the amount of VAT they pay. Also, unlike mandates, a voucher system would not prop up an inefficient and inequitable employment-based insurance system, nor would it require beneficiaries to change health plans when their income, employment, marital status, or other characteristics change. Finally, because the voucher system would be universal no coverage denial, it would not be subject to the adverse selection problem in which a disproportionate share of higher users of care are drawn into the system while the better insurance risks make other arrangements. Individual mandates by themselves remain subject to this serious problem. One very important difference between a universal voucher system and single-payer systems currently proposed is that the latter promise an open-ended entitlement that is often not tied directly to adequate funding. In the voucher system, by contrast, expenditure and revenue are explicitly connected through the dedicated tax. Also, single-payer systems generally provide only a monetary promise; they do not guarantee access to care. Many Medicare beneficiaries today have difficulty finding a physician to accept them as a patient. In a voucher system, everyone would be enrolled in a plan that is held responsible for providing care to its enrollees. Finally, a crucial difference between a voucher system and the other two models is that neither of the other two models makes a significant effort to improve efficiency in the organization and delivery of care. The projected universal voucher system, by contrast, would make plans accountable for quality and service by allowing only qualified plans to enroll patients. Paying a risk-adjusted fee per enrollee (that is, capitation) creates a strong financial incentive for insurance companies to be efficient in care delivery. In short, the projected universal voucher system would be more than just a funding mechanism. It would create a positive dynamic that moves the entire system toward more efficient use of resources and higher-quality care. Initially, all Americans who are not in Medicare, Medicaid, or SCHIP would be notified by their regional health board that they can now choose their health plan or health insurance company through the insurance exchange. Through mailings, the Internet, and other mechanisms, potential enrollees would be informed about the different plans available in their geographic area. Charts would identify the similarities and differences in the various plans: what local hospitals each plan uses, the physicians participating in the plan, the copayments required, and other relevant information. Americans would also be instructed on how to enroll. People with coverage today would be able to keep their current doctor, and many aspects of their plan would remain the same. As stated above, Medicare, Medicaid, SCHIP, and other government health programs would initially remain in place, but participants in these programs would be notified that they could now switch to the voucher system. Those who prefer not to switch would just stay in their current program. For most Americans, enrollment in a health plan under the universal health care voucher system would feel much like what they currently experience through their employer-based coverage, with four important differences. First, they would have a wider choice of health plans. Today most Americans who are covered by their employer have no choice of health plan (Kaiser 2006). They are told who will provide their coverage and what will be covered. Those currently uninsured would experience a new freedom to choose a health plan. Second, Americans would no longer have to be screened to determine their premiums or to determine what will be excluded from coverage for the first year. No health plan or insurance company would be allowed to subject Americans to pretesting or to deny coverage on the basis of preexisting conditions. No one could be denied enrollment or renewal of coverage for any reason. Instead of health plans choosing their enrollees, as is effectively the case today, enrollees would be allowed to choose their health plan. Third, enrollees would pay nothing directly for the set of standard health benefits. The universal health care voucher would cover the full cost. There would be no premiums deducted from paychecks or paid for out of pocket. There would be no deductibles, and many people would find their copayments to be less than what they are currently paying.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.