Single payer doesn’t decrease admin costs
Pearl, MD, professor of surgery at Stanford University, and faculty of the Stanford Graduate School of Business, ‘17
(Robert, “Why A Government-Run, Single-Payer Healthcare Approach Is Doomed To Fail,” March 16,
Myth 1: It Would Lower Administrative Costs
Supporters claim a single-payer system would siphon out billions of dollars in administrative overhead. How they reach this conclusion varies by the source but in each case, a deeper analysis reveals oversimplification and fallacious assumptions.
One line of reasoning is based on the lower cost of healthcare in other countries with a government-run system. But the reduced costs in other nations reflect other factors—their cheaper drug prices, lower wages and higher number of primary care physicians compared to specialists—rather than lower administrative overhead.
A second comparison drawn is between Medicare and commercial insurance in the United States. Here cost is confused with price, and vice versa. The federal government has a unilateral ability to set prices, and often does so at levels below the actual cost of care delivery. When it does this, hospitals and doctors offset the reduced payments they receive from the government by raising prices elsewhere. Published economic analyses indicate that only 90% of cost is reimbursed through Medicare today and that, as a consequence, commercial insurers pay, on average, approximately 120% of the Medicare rates to doctors and hospitals.
Finally, some backers of a single-payer system look at the medical loss ratio (percentage of healthcare premium spent on direct patient care) of some of the publicly traded insurance companies and note that, for some, nearly 20% of their revenues are used for administrative purposes. What is left unsaid is that there are already several not-for-profit insurance programs that spend more than 90% of their revenue on patient care—and as such, little savings would be achieved.
The idea that a government-run plan could function without incurring major administrative costs is naive, especially if fee-for-service is the method of provider reimbursement. In such a system, doctors and hospitals would still need to complete claims forms. Government employees would, in turn, be required to sort through them, make certain they’re appropriate, question coding and pay the providers accordingly. There is little evidence, whether we look at the U.S. Postal Service or the Department of Motor Vehicles, that the government is particularly efficient at these types of administrative tasks.