Single-payer is divisive – polarization will trigger in-fighting if aff passes.
Blendon et al. 21 (Robert J. Blendon, Richard L. Menschel Professor of Public Health and Professor of Health Policy and Political Analysis, John M. Benson, Managing Director, Harvard Opinion Research Program, Harvard University, Eric C. Schneider, Executive Vice President, Quality Measurement and Research Group, National Committee for Quality Assurance, “The Future of Health Policy in a Partisan United States,” JAMA Network, March 5, 2021, https://jamanetwork.com/journals/jama/fullarticle/2777394) VQ
Universal Coverage and National Health Insurance Reform On the issue of universal health insurance coverage, the 2 parties’ constituents appear to be sharply divided. Nearly 9 in 10 Democrats (87%) (n = 703 surveyed) reported that they believe it is the responsibility of the government to ensure all individuals in the US have health insurance coverage, a view shared by fewer than 1 in 4 Republicans (23%) (n = 580 surveyed). Among Democrats, 75% reported that they prefer a health insurance system mostly run by the government, whereas 79% of Republicans reported that they prefer a system based mostly on private health insurance.5 The same survey of 2150 individuals also addressed specific coverage proposals and found majorities of Democrats (n = 703 surveyed) expressed support for each of 3 options: building on the Affordable Care Act (ACA) (93%), Medicare-for-All (85%), and a Medicare buy-in to the ACA sometimes called “the public option” (82%). In contrast, only 30% of Republicans (n = 580 surveyed) expressed support for building on the ACA and 28% supported Medicare-for-All. While 62% of Republicans (n = 580 surveyed) reported that they support a Medicare buy-in to the ACA, that support does not represent an endorsement of the notion that government should ensure universal coverage. In addition, 64% of Republicans reported that they support replacing the ACA with a state-based private health insurance alternative compared with 36% of Democrats (n = 703 surveyed).5 US Health Care System Reform Currently, enthusiasm for broad reform of the US health care system is limited among both parties’ constituents. In a Gallup poll from June to July 2020, 55% of Democrats (n = 407 surveyed) and 53% of Republicans (n = 323 surveyed) indicated that they have a great deal or quite a lot of confidence in the current US medical system.6 Any debate about making substantial changes to the US health care system will encounter the deep division between the 2 parties’ constituents over future federal government involvement in health care. About two-thirds of Democrats (68%) (n = 703 surveyed) indicated that they believe the federal government should be more involved in health care, a view held by only 17% of Republicans (n = 580 surveyed).5 Members of both parties view one issue as a high priority for federal government intervention. In a December 2020 poll that included 328 Democrats and 272 Republicans, taking action to reduce high prescription drug prices was listed by both Democrats and Republicans as among their top 6 priorities (from a list of 23) for the new president and Congress.2 However, Democrats and Republicans in Congress currently disagree on how best to achieve that goal.