Job training and educational elements of the program meet any definition of ‘direct’ fiscal redistribution
Larson ’21 [Sven; February 20; Ph.D., Economics writer with the European Conservative; “The American Welfare State Today,” in Democracy or Socialism, Palgrave Macmillan, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-030-65643-0_5]
European programs are in general more redistributive in nature. However, it matters less to what degree a program is redistributive, than the fact that it is redistributive in the first place. Once the architecture of economic redistribution is there, the quantity of redistribution is more of a technical legislative matter than a principled one. Again, as the three rules of entitlement expansion prescribe, it is easier to expand an already existing program for economic redistribution than it is to create one.
Welfare-State Consensus
Entitlements fall into two categories:
In-kind benefits such as single-payer health care, universal childcare, and tuition-free college;
Cash benefits under the banners of universal basic income or a job guarantee.
The American welfare state is split about evenly between the two categories, but that may change. Congress has not yet copied all the in-kind programs that exist in European welfare states—single-payer health care and universal childcare being two of them—but while such new programs are likely, the debate also continues regarding cash benefits. In addition to paid family leave, the idea of a universal basic income has gained considerable momentum in recent years. This entitlement has been proposed under different labels, one of them being a job guarantee (Murray and Forstater 2013). In this format, every person in America would be entitled to a government job: since the job is guaranteed—the person is entitled to it—government cannot deny to put anyone on its payroll. Even if government has no projects to do for a person applying for the job guarantee, it must employ that person and put him or her on its payroll. This, however, is only a formality; since there does not have to be a need for the labor that the person provides, the job guarantee is in reality an income guarantee in disguise.
While the job-guarantee idea enjoys support exclusively from the left, an income guarantee—a cash benefit without a formal job mandate attached to it–is viewed favorably by a broader audience. Curiously, its transparently redistributive nature has not deterred libertarian support. Gary Johnson, former governor of New Mexico and a 2016 libertarian presidential candidate, is said to have expressed openness to the idea.Footnote10 In 2019, Matthew Feeney with the libertarian Reason Foundation presented what he saw as a libertarian argument for a basic-income entitlement program.Footnote11 A similar argument comes from Matt Zwolinski at Libertarianism.org.Footnote12
Hemel and Fleischer (2017) make a scholarly effort at establishing the libertarian case for an income guarantee. Their contribution is telling of how there is consensus on the welfare state across formal ideological boundaries. Growing, nominally non-socialist support for a basic-income entitlement reveals how pervasive the idea of the socialist end goal has become; it is widely accepted that government ought to engage in economic redistribution.