Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Social Security includes health care access

Frans Pennings 18, Professor of Labour Law and Social Security Law, Utrecht University, the Netherlands and Martin Seeleib-Kaiser, Professor of Comparative Public Policy, Institute of Political Science, Eberhard Karls University of Tübingen, Germany, “Social Security,” Routledge Handbook of the Welfare State, edited by Bent Greve, 2nd ed., Routledge, 06/28/2018, pp. 355–365 DOI.org (Crossref), doi:10.4324/9781315207049-32

The definition of social security Earlier in the chapter, social security was defined as income protection regulated in statutory schemes for the compensation of the loss of income due to materialisation of contingencies closely related to the physical situation of the persons concerned, the loss of work by workers and basic provisions to protect persons from want. This definition attempts to cover the provisions described above. The contingencies covered are traditionally the following: old age, survivors, disability, industrial accidents, unemployment, sickness, and maternity. In the definition it is attempted to characterise these schemes: they are linked with the physical situation of the person which means that he cannot work anymore (sickness, disability, old age) or a personal situation that has led to a loss of income (death of breadwinner). Unemployment is not related to the physical position, but is often the result of economic development. This definition does not mean that there is also an obligation to give protection in all situations which fall within this definition. For instance, self-employed persons are hardly ever protected against loss of income due to economic developments. However, if a scheme meets the definition, it is considered part of social security. Family allowances and healthcare schemes were also considered as falling within the definition. Family allowances were considered necessary, since the incomes of low-paid workers were otherwise insufficient to bear all the costs of living. Healthcare is considered necessary to ensure that everybody has access to healthcare provisions. More generally, even though not addressed by an insurance scheme, meeting the needs of the poor is also part of social security. The Committee on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights (2007), which gives an interpretation of the right to social security laid down in the International Covenant on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights, follows narrowly the contingencies mentioned in the previous paragraph and is not able either to give one single definition. Instead, it needs a three-tier definition to include all the schemes: the right to social security encompasses the right to access and maintain benefits, whether in cash or in kind, without discrimination in order to secure protection, inter alia, from (1) lack of work-related income caused by sickness, disability, maternity, employment injury, unemployment, old age or death of a family member; (2) unaffordable access to healthcare; and (3) insufficient family support, particularly for children and adult dependants. The following sections will discuss criticism of this definition and approach, for instance, in view of the so-called new risks (e.g. the risk of divorce or the ‘risk’ of having to care for another person such as an aged parent). Another point of criticism is that the enumeration is the result of developments across, in particular, European countries. In other continents other risks occur, such as the high impact of AIDS/HIV, tsunamis or draught (Becker et al., 2013). However, so far this has not led to a new definition of social security. The definition is sometimes adapted to fit with the actual question to be answered or research to be done, for instance, if used to describe developments in government expenditure or to compare budgets of countries. However, in discussions on the definition it is important to realise that the term ‘social security’ also has a normative dimension. For this purpose delineation is useful or even necessary. We will discuss this in the next section. The normative dimension of social security Social security as a norm is laid down, in particular, in national constitutions and international instruments. For example, Article 22 of the Universal Declaration of Human Rights of the United Nations provides that ‘Everyone, as a member of society, has the right to social security’ and the International Covenant on Economic, Social, and Cultural Rights recognises ‘the right of everyone to social security, including social insurance’ (Article 9). Although no enforceable rights can be derived from these provisions, member states are given the obligation to elaborate this right (see also Riedel, 2007) and therefore the provisions have indeed a legal meaning. In order to be able to interpret the obligations following from the said instruments, it is necessary to limit the scope of social security to the protection for well-defined risks. Otherwise it is impossible to criticise a state for not fulfilling its obligations. Contingencies in respect of which many states have already shown that they are willing to accept their responsibility for protection are very useful for the interpretation of the term ‘social security’ in international instruments, as mentioned in the previous paragraph. Contingencies for which there is a widespread accepted responsibility are basically related to physical reasons for not being able to work and economic reasons affecting the dependent working populations (including poverty). An example is, in particular, ILO Convention 102, the Social Security (Minimum Standards) Convention in 1952, which addresses the same contingencies as mentioned above. See also below and Dijkhoff (2011). In addition, in other international contexts the term ‘social security’ is used and here a broad interpretation could also lead to unacceptable results for states, so it has to be narrowed down for this purpose. For instance, Article 48 of the Treaty on the Functioning of the European Union (TFEU) requires that the European Parliament and the Council adopt such measures in the field of social security as are necessary to provide freedom of movement for workers. Examples of such measures are the export of benefits. If, for instance, the term ‘social security’ Frans Pennings 360 is interpreted as also including housing benefits or study grants, these would have to be exported. This would be unacceptable for the EU member states. Regulation 883/2004 elaborating Article 48 solves this problem by giving a limitative list of benefits, corresponding with the benefits mentioned above (see also Pennings, 2015). We may conclude that for the purpose of defining the extent of obligations of states and/or international bodies following from international instruments, it is necessary that the scope of social security is limited. The list of risks mentioned above is generally accepted for this purpose. For other purposes the term ‘social security’ may have another meaning. Basically, for the purpose of interpreting international standards, the definition of social security is rather narrow, focused on traditional risks. Criticism on narrowness of the definition: ‘new risks’ The definition given earlier in this chapter is sometimes criticised for being limited to so-called old risks, in particular those relevant to workers (see contributions in EJSS Special Issue, 2005). It is also argued that new risks have to be taken into account: for instance, the loss of income in case of divorce or the need to care for children or relatives, in particular if they become seriously ill. While it is not the definition of social security which is being criticised as such, it is argued that state responsibility should extend to adopt a new risk under the definition. The state should also adopt compensation schemes for loss of income in case of such a new risk. In this discussion it is important to point out that the provisions recognised so far as social security (the ‘old’ risks) fulfil the requirement that their materialisation is not due to the initiative of the claimant. More precisely, it is possible to define precisely when a person is eligible or not, for example, between voluntary and involuntary unemployment. This criterion is closely linked with the insurance character of a large part of the schemes, but is also more generally still relevant, since the sustainability (financing) and legitimacy of the system depend very much on the possibility to control access and use. If one can claim ‘at will’ the system cannot survive. Therefore this principle that the materialisation of the contingency must not depend on personal choices is essential for distinguishing schemes as social security schemes. The distinction between old and new risks on grounds of the possibility to influence one’s own risk is not an absolute one. For instance, unemployed people can to a certain extent influence the duration of their unemployment depending on their willingness and attempts to accept and find work. Also in case of illness there can be large variations in the work which persons are still willing to do. Family benefits are only paid after a couple has taken the initiative to produce a child. If we compare this with a new risk, namely the obligation to care for a seriously ill child, this does not leave much choice, in some situations, to quit or reduce work. The problem is, however, that for the old risks the legal conditions for benefit eligibility can be much more sharply defined and supervised than in the case of the new risks. This makes it more difficult to control access to compensation for such new risks. For instance, in the example of the ill child, it can still be disputed whether the partner, or other family members, of a professional organisation is asked to provide the care. And in case of care for other family members, friends or relatives the question also arises if the person concerned has to undertake the task of caring or whether somebody else can be asked. Comparable discussions arise in case of divorce insurance. The new risks make supervision difficult and would require a thorough investigation of the private situation of the claimant. Study grants and housing benefits also provide for income compensation and could therefore be considered a form of social security. However, also for these risks the problem is that there is Social security 361 a choice for claimants to influence their materialisation; moreover, there can be different views on whether these risks should be collectively borne than in the case of the traditional risks. This does not mean, of course, that states cannot make arrangements for such contingencies, but they fall outside the concept of social security generally used. Is the concept too Europe-centred? Another criticism on the social security definition is that it is too Europe-centred. Indeed, the history of European schemes was highly influential on the types of risks to be covered and the ways protection is ensured. Critics argue that in particular in developing countries their economies are still at a stage that is very far from being able to establish the ‘Western-type’ protection schemes against, for instance, unemployment and disability, in particular because of their large informal economies. Moreover, they argue that the most important risks which affect the lives of their people, such as drought, earthquakes and tsunamis, HIV/aids and large movements of refugees and other migrants, are not taken into account. Although these are very valuable criticisms, at this stage of the discussion it is not yet possible to define more generally the measures to be taken to respond to these contingencies and to know what their long-term impact is. Therefore it is premature to incorporate such contingencies into the definition of social security. Further research on these issues is necessary (see Becker et al., 2013). The conclusion from the above is that although the contents of the concept of social security are not fixed forever, the present definition is useful to elaborate obligations of states to ensure income protection of their citizens. Types of schemes that can serve to realise social security In the previous section I discussed the types of contingencies falling within the social security concept. The second question is which types of schemes can serve to realise social security. As we saw above, social insurance schemes were established to make workers less dependent on poor relief provisions. A first question is therefore whether the successor of poor relief, social assistance, is part of social security. This is particularly relevant in view of the question of how states can fulfil their obligation to provide for social security. In my view social assistance is part of the social security system. This does not mean that (international) obligations to provide social security can always be fulfilled by social assistance only. For instance, ILO Convention 121 does not allow means-tested benefits as a way to provide income compensation for the victims of industrial accidents. The view that social assistance belongs to social security is based on the fact that currently most, if not all, social assistance schemes do not essentially differ from other types of schemes, except from the fact that income of claimants is taken into account for benefit eligibility (means- test). Claimants have, however, a legally enforceable right to income if the conditions are satisfied; also their legal position is often well defined. Moreover, means-testing is nowadays not limited to social assistance and the distinction between the traditional schemes and social assistance is declining. Insurance-type schemes sometimes have means-tested elements, for instance, for supplements to the benefit for dependants, or because of the nature of the benefit (e.g. in case of survivor benefits). Therefore there is no good reason to exclude social assistance from the concept of social security. Second, the question is whether social security is strictly limited to public schemes. As discussed at the start of this chapter, acknowledgement of state responsibility for income protection Frans Pennings 362 was at the root of social security, thus stressing the importance of public responsibility. Of course, income protection can also be organised by other parties, including employers, family members, mutual funds and private funds. This raises the question whether such provisions are also to be counted as social security. This question has become more relevant now that in many countries the role of the state is being reduced and some public tasks are privatised, including parts of social security. There is nothing against including such forms in the concept of social security, for instance, for calculating expenditure on social issues or income redistribution. However, in view of the normative dimension the issue is different, since again the question has to be answered whether the state has fulfilled its obligations. Because of the impact upon the legal position of the persons concerned, it still makes a very important difference as to who is responsible for income redistribution. The normative dimension requires that the term ‘social security’ is limited to those forms of income protection that are defined by statutory law giving the core obligations to be fulfilled. Within this context private parties can also be given the task of providing an income. For instance, if the employer has a statutory obligation to continue to pay wages to ill employees, this obligation and payment may be considered as social security. If, however, the employer pays the employee money on the basis of an individual or collective employment contract, this is outside the scope of social security. Income protection can be organised in various ways. The current forms may be characterised as follows. Social insurance, where the insured receive benefits or services in exchange for contributions. There are two main schemes: employee insurance schemes, limited to workers and certain assimilated categories; and residence schemes, covering all residents. The schemes are designed for specific contingencies and define the level and duration of benefit. In case of a low benefit and/or limited duration, recourse has to be made to schemes to supplement these schemes, which are often means-tested (i.e. they are paid only if a person has less than a certain amount of income). Employees’ insurance schemes are often administered by organisations of social partners, but this is not always necessarily the case. Public bodies may also have this task. Residence schemes are administered by public bodies. In some systems statutory law allows or obliges private parties (including employers) to take over part of the income protection (previously or still currently) organised by social insurance. This was discussed above. Universal benefits. These differ from the residence schemes mentioned above, as the latter schemes are based on insurance and are thus contributory. Universal schemes are non-contributory benefits without a means-test for all residents. Examples are family allowances or public pensions. Strictly speaking, social assistance schemes can also be universal; however, because of their very important characteristic of being means-tested, social assistance benefits are often put in a separate category. Minimum benefits. These provide for a minimum income for particular groups with a low income (e.g. for disabled persons or the elderly) and are paid from taxes. The difference with public assistance is mainly that these benefits generally do not have a means-test on the capital. Social assistance (means-tested benefits). These benefits are paid to guarantee the subsistence level as defined in the country in question. For this purpose the income and capital of the person (and often also other family members) are taken into account. Social security may also be realised in the form of services (e.g. by means of delivering special services). Healthcare schemes often provide care in the form of services rather than in cash.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.