Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

‘Social Security’ includes only elderly and disability benefits, which are a distinct subset of ‘benefits received under the Social Security Act.’ Massive limits explosion to all social insurance programs otherwise.

Faris ’16 [Robert J. Faris and Randall L. Dunn; January 16, 2016; Federal Bankruptcy Judges, writing over the dissent of Meredith A. Jury, which disagrees with the interpretation of ‘benefits received under the Social Security Act’ rather than ‘Social Security’; Westlaw, “In re Adinolfi,” 543 B.R. 612]

Judicial decisions, even those that are not binding on this Panel, are an excellent source of interpretive guidance. There are no decisions addressing whether the SSA exclusion covers Adoption Assistance payments. Several courts have considered a related issue: whether unemployment insurance payments are “benefits received under the Social Security Act.” Most of those courts have held that unemployment compensation is not excluded. See, e.g., In re Gentry, 463 B.R. 526 (Bankr.D.Colo.2011). A minority of courts have held that the exclusion applies. See, e.g., In re Munger, 370 B.R. at 23–26.

1. Construction of the individual words

We begin with the individual words in the phrase, and then turn to the phrase as a whole.

The word “benefits” does not present a problem in this case. No one denies that the Adoption Assistance payments which the Debtor receives are “benefits.”

The word “received,” at least in isolation, also presents no difficulty. There is no question that the Debtor “receives” the Adoption Assistance payments.

The word “under” has many meanings, but we can reject most of them because they do not make sense in this context. The meanings that make sense here are “subject to the authority, control, guidance, or instruction of,” Merriam–Webster's Collegiate Dictionary 1283 (10th ed.2002), or “in accordance with (some regulative power or principle),” Oxford English Dictionary, www.oed.org. Significantly for this case, the dictionary definitions do not support the proposition that “under” means that the subject is under the exclusive control of something.

The “Social Security Act” is codified at 42 U.S.C.A. §§ 301– 1397mm.4 The SSA was first enacted in 1935 and has been amended hundreds of times since then. See generally Historical Background and Development of Social Security, https://www.ssa.gov/history/briefhistory3.html (last accessed Dec. 3, 2015). It has become a sprawling statute, filling twelve volumes of the United States Code Annotated and providing for many benefit programs, some of which are familiar and others obscure. These programs have a bewildering variety of funding formulae and administrative mechanisms. The federal government funds and administers some of the programs itself, but most of the programs contemplate some degree of state involvement, and many are jointly funded and operated by the federal and state governments. The following summary does not include all such programs and dramatically simplifies the program requirements for almost all of them. Our purpose is to emphasize the wide variation in the programs authorized by the SSA and the futility of picking and choosing which programs are “under” the SSA.

a. Federally-administered programs

Some SSA programs are almost entirely operated and funded by the federal government. But even these programs often contemplate some state involvement. These include:

• The program that most people simply call “Social Security,” which provides “old age,” survivors, and disability insurance benefits. 42 U.S.C.A. §§ 401–434. (Benefits are also available to the survivors of certain railroad retirees. Id. § 402(l). The federal government pays the entire cost of this program. *617 Id. § 401(a). The states have little to do with its administration, with one important exception: a state may elect to have a state agency, rather than the federal government, make determinations of disability. If a state so elects, the federal government retains supervision of the state agency's performance and reimburses the state's administrative costs. Id. § 421. (A special provision applies if a state or political subdivision elects to allow its employees to participate in these benefits. Id. § 418.)

• Medicare, id. §§ 1395–1395kkk–1. Medicare is mostly operated by the federal government, through private companies acting as third-party administrators. Id. § 1395kk–1. The states may elect to be involved in Medicare by certifying the qualifications of certain health care providers. Id. § 1395aa.

• Supplemental security income (“SSI”) for the low-income aged, blind, and disabled. Id. §§ 1381–1383f. This program contemplates some coordination with the states; if a state offers similar benefits, the state and the federal government may agree that the federal government will pay the state benefits on behalf of the state, and the state will reimburse the federal government for the state benefits paid plus a per-payment administrative fee. Id. § 1382e.

• Special benefits for World War II veterans, id. §§ 1001–1013. The SSA provides that, if a state provides comparable benefits, the federal government may agree with the state to pay those benefits on behalf of the state, and the state reimburses the federal government for the benefits paid plus an administrative fee. Id. § 1010a.

b. Federal funding of state-paid benefits

For other programs, the SSA provides that, if a state creates a program of a certain kind that meets detailed requirements (and is usually subject to federal approval of the state government's plan), the federal government will pay all or part of the benefits and the administrative costs of the program. These include:

• Medicaid, pursuant to which the federal government makes grants to states operating plans for medical assistance that meet the detailed and voluminous requirements of § 1396a. The federal government pays a percentage of the benefits paid by the states. The percentage depends on a comparison of the state's per capita income with the national per capita income, but is not less than 50% or more than 83%. Id. § 1396d(b). The federal government also pays a portion (usually 75%) of the state's expenses for administering various parts of the program. Id. § 1396b.

• Programs in Guam, Puerto Rico, and the Virgin Islands providing old age benefits, id. §§ 301–306, where the federal government pays the territorial government half of the benefits payments, not to exceed a capped amount per beneficiary, and half of the administrative costs, id. § 303.

• The Stephanie Tubbs Jones Child Welfare Services Program, id. §§ 620–628, under which the federal government reimburses states for 75% of the benefits paid and administrative costs for certain child welfare programs, subject to an aggregate cap. The same program authorizes matching grants to states and Indian tribes that provide “family connection programs.” Id. § 627.

• Programs for family support, family preservation, family reunification, and adoption support services, id. §§ 629629i. The federal government pays the states up to 75% of the cost of *618 such programs plus certain grants for program administration and other purposes. Id. §§ 629d, 629g.

• Foster care and adoption assistance, id. §§ 670–679c. The federal government pays the “federal medical assistance percentage” of the covered benefit payments, 75% of parent training expenses, and 50% of operating expenses, id. § 674, plus possible incentive payments, id. § 673b. This program includes the Adoption Assistance payments at issue in this appeal.

• Aid to the blind in Puerto Rico, Guam, and the Virgin Islands, id. §§ 1201–1206. The federal government pays up to half of the benefits, subject to a dollar cap per beneficiary, and half of the territorial government's administrative expenses. Id. § 1203.

c. Federal reimbursement for administrative costs

In a third category of programs, the SSA provides that, if a state creates a benefit program of a particular type that meets specified requirements, the federal government will reimburse the state for some or all of the reasonable costs of administering the program, but not any benefit payments. These include:

• Unemployment compensation, id. §§ 501–504, 1101–1110. Although the states fund these benefits, the federal government plays a crucial fiscal role. In order to receive federal reimbursement for the state's administrative costs, the state must pay over to the federal government all taxes and other contributions to the state's programs. The federal government holds the funds in the Unemployment Trust Fund and returns the funds to the states upon requisition. The federal government has the authority to make loans to states if the state needs money to pay benefits. Id. §§ 1321–1324. The federal government also funds part of the benefits in certain circumstances: if the federal government legislates to extend the usual 26–week benefit period, the federal government pays 50% of the extended benefits. See In re Kucharz, 418 B.R. 635 (Bankr.C.D.Ill.2009).

• Programs for child support collection and the determination of paternity, 42 U.S.C.A. §§ 651–669b. The federal government reimburses up to 66% of the cost of operating qualified programs, id. § 655, plus certain incentive payments, id. § 658a.

d. Federal block grants and loans

In a fourth category, the SSA provides that the federal government provides “block grants” (and in some cases loans) to states (and Indian tribes) that enact and administer programs meeting specified criteria. The amount of the grant is sometimes entirely independent of the state's outlays but in other cases is based on a formula that is tied (more or less loosely) to such costs. These include (among others):

• Temporary Assistance to Needy Families (“TANF”), id. §§ 601619. The TANF block grants are based on a lengthy and complicated set of criteria applied by the Secretary of the Treasury that depend only in part on the benefits actually paid by each state. Id. § 603. The states have latitude in spending the block grant money, id. § 604, but the SSA imposes certain strict limitations on the states' payments of benefits, e.g., id. §§ 607, 608.

• Maternal and child health services, id. §§ 701–713. A fixed amount of money is allocated based on a formula that is not directly related to the states' expenses of such programs. Id. § 702(c).

• Child care services, protective services for children and adults, foster care services, adult day care services, and other programs generally described in 42 U.S.C.A. § 1397a. A fixed aggregate sum is allocated among the states based on population, id. § 1397b, and the presence of “qualified empowerment zones” in the state, id. § 1397f.

• Elder justice programs, id. §§ 1397j–1397m–5. Entities eligible to receive these grants include states and their political subdivisions as well as Indian tribes and other public and private entities. Id. § 1397j(7). The Department of Health and Human Services allocates a fixed sum among grant applicants on a more or less discretionary basis.

• State Children's Health Program, commonly known as “SCHIP,” id. §§ 1397aa-mm. This program provides funds to states that maintain qualified and approved programs to provide health insurance to targeted low-income children under Medicaid or otherwise. A fixed sum is allocated among qualified states based on a complicated formula that, very broadly summarized, covers half of the state's deemed cost of the program. Id. § 1397dd.

• The Ticket to Work and Self–Sufficiency Program, id. § 1320b–19, under which the federal government provides a voucher to qualified disabled beneficiaries which the beneficiary may use to obtain services from “employment networks.” States may elect to establish employment networks and receive payments under the program. The employment network receives payments for each month during which the beneficiary is not receiving specified welfare benefits (presumably because the beneficiary is employed) or is making progress toward employment. Id. § 1320b–19(h); see also id. § 1320b–21 (describing another similar program).

In short, the “Social Security Act” encompasses a wide spectrum of programs. Most of the programs involve some degree of state participation, and the extent of the states' involvement varies widely from program to program.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.