American unipolarity is peaceful and sustainable
Terhalle 13 Maximilian Terhalle studied international politics , history and international law, he received his master's degree in political science, modern history and constitutional and international law. He attended the Summer School in International Politics at the University of Cambridge and received his Master’s in International and National Middle Eastern Politics, “Is Unipolarity Peaceful?”, ResearchGate, Aug 5, 2013, https://www.researchgate.net/publication/258143005_Is_Unipolarity_Peaceful
Unipolarity is more peaceful than what theorists predict. In causal terms, its dynamics might be less unidirectional than what is often assumed. First, contrary to Monteiro’s assumption, the character of today’s aggregation mechanisms is not adversarial. This is because the nature of polarity has changed over time. Second, in contrast to domestic alliance aspects, Monteiro’s structural inclinations lead him to overlook the importance of domestic politics when analyzing the targets of the unipole’s ‘temptation to re-engineer the system’. Third, since Monteiro believes that wars against smaller states are very likely, he seems to assume a deterministic stance, thereby leaving no room for US diplomacy to reject such determinism at opportune moments. Finally, neglecting economic aspects, Monteiro does not recognize the socio-political effects of the security-economics nexus on smaller states. For more than ten years, William Wohlforth’s (1999) contributions to the study of unipolarity have, generally speaking, defined the debate—notwithstanding the substantial criticism his arguments have encountered (see Layne, 2006). Nuno Monteiro (2011–12) has now taken a fresh look at Wohlforth’s central proposi-tions. At its core, his highly original piece asks whether or not unipolarity will be peaceful, thereby critically complementing the existing analyses focusing on its durability.