Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Universal healthcare prevents military recruitment

Kels 08 (Capt. Charlie Kels, judge advocate general in the U.S. Air Force, 12-22-2008, "Bump in the rug," Modern Healthcare, https://www.modernhealthcare.com/article/20081222/MAGAZINE/812199928/bump-in-the-rug) @HA?

Healthcare reform could be costly in a different way for military Assuming that campaign proposals translate into government policy, the incoming administration and Congress will establish a new public health insurance plan that provides "the same kind of coverage that members of Congress give themselves." Uninsured Americans who can't afford to pay for the plan will receive a tax subsidy to do so, the cost of which will presumably be financed in part by a payroll tax on large businesses that don't already insure their employees. By all accounts, a sizable portion of Americans appear ready to embrace this proposal, or a universal healthcare plan like it. In addition to the results of the most recent national elections, the Harvard School of Public Health found in a poll conducted earlier this year that a plurality (45%) of respondents who said they understood what the term "socialized medicine" meant also felt that such a system would be better than the current one. Fully 70% of Democrats felt this way, as did 55% of young adults aged 18 to 34. If "socialized medicine" no longer functions as a pejorative, then it would seem that those who oppose such a policy have lost the philosophical ground war. Some form of socialized medicine is on its way. Regardless of one's views on healthcare policy, one thing we can probably all agree on is that government-funded universal coverage is going to be expensive. In addition to the significant direct costs associated with such a plan, there are indirect costs as well (just as there are to having millions of uninsured and underinsured citizens). These indirect costs need to be factored in, or at least considered, in order to paint a fuller picture of what the final tab is going to run. Thus far, at least, one of the seemingly overlooked items has been the potential impact of universal healthcare on military recruitment and retention, and the corresponding cost of rectifying this unintended effect. Whatever the complaints and negative press aimed at the Military Health System, the fact remains that the comprehensive medical care provided to active-duty service members and their families constitutes a significant benefit of military service. The Defense Department estimates the average annual premium of a comparable civilian plan at $15,804 per family. Providing a national health insurance plan thus places the government in a possible Catch-22: the better the plan is perceived as being, and the more" generous the proposed tax subsidies are, the less comparatively attractive the military's medical program becomes to those considering joining or extending their commitments. The point here is emphatically not that our nation's military is a mercenary force fighting for health benefits. There are many ways to obtain healthcare coverage that require infinitely less effort, risk and sacrifice than donning the uniform and taking up the profession of arms. Rather, what's worth noting is that the medical care provided and paid for by the military enables the government to pay our service members less in salary, and instead tout the "indirect compensation" associated with military service. A high-quality universal healthcare plan might require us to pay our service members more to rebalance the scales. Each year, the Defense Department mails out a "personal statement of military compensation" to all uniformed personnel. This document purports to make military compensation more "visible," primarily by highlighting the indirect benefits of service, particularly medical care. The drafters of the statement are refreshingly candid as to their intentions, suggesting that the reader peruse it "to help determine whether specific civilian employment offers would let you maintain the same standard of living you had while serving in the military." Ignore the pay charts, the document all but implores, as the personal statement is a truer gauge of whether a civilian position will bring the same standard of living as military employment. The primary purpose of military medical care is national security readiness; the nation needs a healthy military force that can perform the required mission. A secondary purpose--at least since 1966 legislation establishing a Pentagon-run health insurance plan--is to reward those who serve, as well as their dependents and retirees. Universal healthcare operates under a different set of assumptions. Its impetus is neither military readiness nor support of those who wear the uniform, but instead equity and humanity. These principles need not be mutually exclusive, but their simultaneous implementation may require rethinking military entitlements. If the Defense Department can no longer convincingly claim that its healthcare program provides sufficient indirect compensation to make military pay competitive, even if not lucrative, then innovative ideas may be essential to provide incentives to serve. Perhaps military retirement will need to vest at 10 years instead of 20. Maybe the government will need to match service members' Thrift Savings Plan contributions, like it currently does for certain civilian employees. In other words, depending on how recruitment and retention trends respond to the rollout of national healthcare coverage, something in the equation may have to give. It's an added cost of an already expensive proposition. We're better off thinking about it sooner rather than later

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.