A local jobs guarantee solves better and a complementary currency system can pay for it.
Forstater 18 (Mathew Forstater, PhD, professor in Economics and the Research Director of the Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity at UMKC. 2018. “Complementary currencies in the solidarity economy: The local job guarantee,” Full Employment and Social Justice: Solidarity and Sustainability, pp.159-162.) @HA?
According to neo-chartalism, a non-convertible floating currency is a monopoly of the issuer. The issuer has not only the power to impose debt obligations, but to designate what is acceptable to settle those obligations, what it will accept at its pay offices. In this way, the issuer can create a demand for otherwise worthless bits of paper, leading to general acceptability. The monopoly issuer can use its own monopoly money to purchase goods and services, including labor-power. These and related powers constitute a menu of instruments that may be used to conduct policy based on the principles of functional finance (Forstater 1999). Under such a system, the issuer’s budget may be freely used to promote job creation and other socio-economic goals. Such a system crucially depends on a one-to-one correspondence between money and the issuer, and only with such a strict correspondence does the issuer’s debt become truly riskless, enabling the issuer to buy anything for sale—and settle any obligation—denominated in the unit of account (Goodhart 1998). When communities forfeit their monetary sovereignty and the strict correspondence is severed, as in the current structure of the European EMU, they do face financial constraints, and currency risk is replaced by default risk. In 2012, I visited Italy to speak about the European crisis. The options for real change considered by the panelists included: (1) exit from the EMU by Italy or other individual member nations; (2) radical reform of the structure of the monetary union (or the use of “emergency” measures hidden in the fine print), for example, seriously increasing the deficit-GDP and debt-GDP ratios, zero-interest or low interest (or negative nominal interest!) loans to individual nations; (3) an end to the monetary union and a return to national currencies; and (4) the creation of a fiscal authority at the Euro level to work in concert with the ECB, that is, a “United States of Europe” (Kregel 1999). During the discussion period, a young audience member asked, “So, short of waiting for the politicians in our countries or the bureaucrats in the EU to implement changes they lack the will and/or the power to undertake, is there nothing we can do to help the unemployed and their families in our cities and localities?” While a second-best solution, because they will still be operating within the constraints of the monetary union, we proposed communities consider issuing a form of complementary currency (CC) quite consistent with neo-chartalist principles, and that a local job guarantee (JG) program be implemented to employ the unemployed in community service jobs. In fact, the general idea of alternative currencies is not one that is new in Europe. In addition, the proposal is one that could be applied in other contexts where a full-blown national JG is not possible, either due to the constraints of some type of fixed exchange rate (whether a peg to another country’s currency or a monetary union) or because of political obstacles. In the USA, for example, proposals for a job guarantee have been put forward as national policies due to the flexibility the federal government has in paying for the program. This flexibility stems from the ability of the Treasury and the Central Bank to work in cooperation to implement fiscal and monetary policies. There are many obstacles, however, to government policies at the federal level, including political, administrative, legislative, and ideological. An alternative route to job creation at the local level would be to use a complementary currency to pay for community service employment. In this way, cities, counties, or states that are currency users in terms of dollars can become currency issuers in terms of the complementary currency. In addition, this form of local financing dovetails nicely with the focus of most job guarantee proposals on local administration and management of JG activities by local governments, non-profits, and NGOs. There are numerous other potential benefits of the local solution for individuals, families, neighborhoods, communities, and regions (Forstater 2013). It is possible that the benefits of a well-managed local currency may mean its implementation is desirable even in communities within a nation operating a neo-chartalist monetary system and managing its budgets according to the principles of functional finance (including a job guarantee), and during prosperous times and not only in the event of a crisis. 7.1 Money, Employment, and Complementary Currencies When there is unemployment, jobs and money, not resources and goods, are scarce. In a full-employment economy, there is a sense in which resources are scarce. Economizing is important, as resources can only be allocated to some use if they are removed from another productive activity. In an economic system with unemployment, however, resources are not scarce, as production may be increased by employing the unemployed resources. But there are other kinds of scarcity in the economy suffering from unemployment: “What is scarce is money. The lack of money to spend on the goods is what keeps the unemployed resources from producing more goods” (Lerner 1951, p. 147). Historically, many complementary currencies appeared during times of economic crisis, when money was not adequately available. If the amount of national currency was not sufficient to meet the community’s needs, they would simply create their own. During the Great Depression, there were dozens, if not hundreds, of cases of local currency, just in the USA (Gatch 2011). In Europe as well, numerous complementary currencies appeared during the Great Depression, and many exist there today. The contemporary literature on complementary currencies acknowledges and accepts the central insights of chartalism and functional finance. Bernard Lietaer and Jacqui Dunne, in Rethinking Money (2013), write: [A] sovereign government does not really “need” to raise taxes to pay for its expenses. Once this is understood, it becomes clear that neither taxes nor government bonds “finance” government spending. Instead, taxes are required to give value to money. (Lietaer and Dunne 2013, p. 27) In People Money: The Promise of Regional Currencies (2012), the authors state that “[i]f the authorities want to encourage regional currencies, so that their full potential can be realised, the most effective way of doing this would be to accept them in payment of specific taxes” (Kennedy et al. 2012, p. 68). Lietaer and his co-authors, in Money and Sustainability: The Missing Link (2012, pp. 133–138), cite authors such as Wray (1998), Mosler (1994), and others in support of what they call the “Fiat Currency Paradigm,” which they contrast with the “Official Paradigm” (i.e., the orthodox view). The core characteristic of the fiat currency paradigm, they argue, is that, “the systemic role of taxes is to give value to a currency, which, in the case of a fiat currency, would otherwise have no intrinsic value whatsoever” (Lietaer et al. 2012, p. 136). Historical analyses of what has been called “tax anticipation scrip” (essentially what neo-chartalists have termed “tax-driven money”) in the USA in the 1930s now include references to chartalism (Gatch 2011). Articles analyzing local currencies in journals such as the International Journal of Community Currencies and the Journal of Cleaner Production likewise reference the modern money literature (see, e.g., Dittmer 2013). Modern money theory has until recently not reciprocated this engagement of the complementary currency literature with neo-chartalism, functional finance, and the JG. This does seem to be changing a bit, however, and there have also been some notable exceptions, such as Peacock (2006, 2013). One of the most important links between chartalism and complementary currencies has been the Buckaroo program at the University of Missouri—Kansas City (UMKC).