Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Empirics Prove complementary currency is achievable and effective

Forstater 18 (Mathew Forstater, PhD, professor in Economics and the Research Director of the Binzagr Institute for Sustainable Prosperity at UMKC. 2018. “Complementary currencies in the solidarity economy: The local job guarantee,” Full Employment and Social Justice: Solidarity and Sustainability, pp.162-164.) @HA?

7.2 The UMKC Buckaroo Program: A Neo-Chartalist Complementary Currency When the Center for Full Employment and Price Stability (C-FEPS) moved to the Economics Department at UMKC in the fall of 1999, the department commenced a service-learning program that would encourage students to do community service while learning about modern monetary systems and government budgets. Rather than directly requiring students to do community service, the department created its own currency, called the “Buckaroo.” The name of the currency is a play on the words “kangaroo” (the UMKC university mascot), “buck” (a common slang term for a dollar), and—being located in Kansas City—the word for cowboy derived from the Spanish, vaquero (“Buckaroo”). On the face of the Buckaroo is the inscription: “this note represents one hour of community service by a UMKC student,” and the note is denominated as “One ROO Hour.” The note also has a picture of Thorstein Veblen, the Institutionalist economist who held a position for a time at the University of Missouri, and whose work is closely studied by students at UMKC. Instead of just requiring students to do service, professors include as part of the course requirements that students pay a tax of, for example, four Buckaroos per week for the semester. Approved community service providers (state and local government offices, public schools, NGOs, and not-for-profit agencies) submit requests to the UMKC Economics Department “Treasury” for student hours and are awarded “special drawing rights” (SDRs) as long as basic health and safety and liability standards are met. Service providers pay students one Buckaroo per hour, which is equivalent to spending by the Treasury. Students pay their tax with the Buckaroo notes they earn performing community service, and the requirement is met when their tax liability is met. There is no limit to how many Buckaroos a student can earn. Some students will perform more hours of service than that needed to satisfy their tax liability. Buckaroos are freely transferable, so they may exchange for goods and services or other currencies. Buckaroos are a floating exchange rate currency, in other words UMKC does not peg the exchange rate between buckaroos and dollars, for example. Buckaroos are also non-convertible, meaning UMKC doesn’t promise to convert it to anything, such as gold. The Buckaroo is a case of public monopoly, since UMKC is the sole supplier and it is against the rules to counterfeit Buckaroos. The Buckaroo is a sovereign currency, issued by a monopoly supplier who imposes a tax liability in its otherwise worthless currency. UMKC only promises it will accept Buckaroos in payment of taxes. The dollar is also a sovereign, non-convertible, floating currency without intrinsic value and operated as a public monopoly. The only promise the US Treasury makes is that it will accept dollars in payment of taxes. UMKC always runs a Buckaroo deficit, because students always earn more than their tax liability (they lose some, keep some as souvenirs, etc.). UMKC’s Buckaroo fiscal deficit is exactly equal to the Buckaroos saved by the students. The value of the Buckaroo is a function of what the students have to do to earn a Buckaroo from UMKC, and is unaffected by the size of the deficit or the amount of Buckaroo spending by the department. UMKC Buckaroo spending, however, does not depend on collecting taxes. Certainly, UMKC does not need to borrow Buckaroos in order to spend. A UMKC graduate, Fadhel Kaboub, earned his PhD and left to become a professor at Denison University, where he started a similar program there called “Denison Volunteer Dollars.” If UMKC decided it would give up its currency, and join a monetary union with Denison, then UMKC could not pay students unless it collected taxes first, or borrowed DVDs in private markets. UMKC would no longer be a monetary sovereign. It would no longer be a money monopolist. It could no longer continue to run fiscal deficits to create full employment and satisfy the desire of students to save. Denison would tell UMKC it better get its fiscal house in order, and so force UMKC to accept an austerity program. When Greece, Spain, Italy, and other member nations joined the Euro, it put itself in exactly the same position as UMKC, if UMKC gave up the Buckaroo and joined Denison in a monetary union (or pegged the Buckaroo to the DVD). Before adopting the Euro, the member nations were also monetary sovereigns, and their currencies were also a non-convertible floating currencies backed by the tax system. But when they adopted the Euro, they voluntarily gave up their monetary sovereignty. They are no longer money monopolists. They are no longer a currency issuers, but now, like households, they are currency users. Short of UMKC voluntarily giving up its monetary sovereignty, however, the similarities between the Buckaroo and other non-convertible, floating currencies such as the dollar: Governments issue money to buy what they need; they tax to generate a demand for that money; and then they accept the money in payment of the tax. If a deficit results, that simply indicates that the population wishes to hoard some of the money. The deficit is of no consequence to the government; it merely allows the population to save in the form of government money. If the government wants to, it can let the population trade the money for interest-earning government bonds, but the government never needs to borrow its own money from the public. Taxes and bonds, therefore, have nothing to do with financing a government’s spending. (Wray 2000, pp. 61–62)

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.