Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Localism solves existential environmental and socioeconomic risks – key to both the proximate efficacy of policy and a race to the top informing global policy – especially on climate and inequality

Murray ‘19 [Ashley Murray, D.C. Bureau Chief at the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, MA Media Communication, specialization in Environmental Journalism, Point Park University; internally quoting Joseph Sabino Mistick, Duquesne University law professor, and George Dougherty, University of Pittsburgh public administration professor; “Sticking their tongue out and sticking their nose in -- cities try to tackle social issues,” Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 6-2-2019, https://www.post-gazette.com/local/city/2019/06/02/Is-action-at-the-city-level-a-trend-Experts-and-mayors-say-yes-and-no/stories/201906020044]

Mayor Bill Peduto sat alongside business, nonprofit and education leaders at Carnegie Mellon University in April to talk about the role that cities can play — in basically, saving the planet. The panel discussion focused on the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals, 17 areas to be accomplished by 2030, including no poverty; zero hunger; gender equality; decent work and economic growth; and sustainable cities. “There’s been an amazing shift over the past 10 years in the role of cities in addressing major issues, whether climate change or [the] refugee crisis,” Mr. Peduto said. “Organizations, maybe not federal governments, understand that solutions lie at the local level.” Cities have been flexing their muscles. Albuquerque, N.M., raised the minimum wage to $8.20. Georgetown, Texas, only buys renewable energy. Minneapolis mandates paid sick leave for businesses with six or more employees. Cuyahoga County, Ohio, voted last week to ban plastic bags. And dozens of cities are refusing to aid federal law enforcement on matters of immigration, becoming so-called “sanctuary cities.” Law and municipal government experts say that cities “sticking their tongue out” at state and federal government is nothing new. Others see a trend that is wasting taxpayer money as cities like Pittsburgh take bold political stances that end up in drawn-out legal battles. While jockeying between levels of government is characteristic of a federalist system, critics argue that state power over cities is settled law. Pittsburgh's progressive agenda Since taking the reins in 2014, the Peduto administration has prioritized networking with other cities, joining up with the Rockefeller Foundation's 100 Resilient Cities. Mr. Peduto attended the U.N. climate conference in Poland in December; in April, he spoke on gun reform at the U.S. Conference of Mayors in Ohio. But several items on his progressive agenda have been challenged. Pittsburgh currently is mired in lawsuits over restrictions on firearms and requiring businesses to offer paid sick leave and landlords to accept federal low-income housing vouchers. “I stood up and said wait a minute, City of Pittsburgh, you don’t have the authority,” said the Apartment Association of Metropolitan Pittsburgh’s Jim Eichenlaub. His organization won two lower court rulings against the city’s ordinance that told landlords they had to accept federal Section 8 vouchers. The city has appealed the ruling to the Pennsylvania Supreme Court. Meanwhile, the state’s highest court has yet to rule on the city’s paid sick leave ordinance; it heard arguments in the fall of 2018. The city invited several more legal challenges in April when it passed three gun-control ordinances. Council members Corey O’Connor and Erika Strassburger wrote the laws in conjunction with the mayor’s office, just seven weeks after a gunman killed 11 people at the Tree of Life synagogue. Local, state and national gun-rights groups, including the National Rifle Association, filed multiple lawsuits, pointing to Pennsylvania law that prohibits local governments from regulating firearms. Mr. Peduto vows that the city will take the fight all the way to the U.S. Supreme Court. “We go through these periods in which cities choose to make political statements by adopting laws that they should know full well they do not have the authority to adopt,” said Joseph Sabino Mistick, Duquesne University law professor and former Allegheny County and City of Pittsburgh employee. “We’re seeing that quite a bit in Pittsburgh. They are political statements, ideology statements. From a common sense point of view, some of them are quite appealing, but they, in many cases, are just not legal,” he said. “… When they do that, it’s not without consequences and cost to the taxpayers.” (The city maintains it’s receiving pro bono legal representation from the national gun-control advocacy group Everytown for Gun Safety.) But state power over cities — established in a late 19th century “practical and longstanding” ruling, commonly referred to as Dillon’s Rule — isn’t going away any time soon, Mr. Mistick said. A 1907 case called Hunter v. City of Pittsburgh, which decided a debate over the joining of Pittsburgh with what was then Allegheny City, is still cited as a landmark case upholding the legal framework. If Mr. Peduto or city council want change on firearms, family leave or a whole other host of issues, they should be “knocking on doors” in Harrisburg, Mr. Mistick said. A trend? So is city action on hot-button issues a trend? Yes and no, experts say. “In a lot of ways in the history of U.S., this actually has been going on from the very beginning,” said George Dougherty, a University of Pittsburgh public administration professor. Before World War II, the federal government was limited in scope, and “it was the New Yorks and Chicagos and New Orleans of the world that brought about substantial changes ... that made cities a lot cleaner. Public health became a focus, and the leaders in that really were cities,” he said. It’s not odd for them to take the lead, he said. Think: LGBTQ protections. “What is odd and interesting is that now cities are beginning to flex more muscle in taking on issues that have been defined as federal in the past 30 or 40 years,” he said. A popular argument from proponents for local action is that gridlock in Washington is pushing cities to act. Another argument is that the trend is not so much in cities taking action, but in the “rapid adoption” of preemptive legislation, as Lauren E. Phillips details in a 2017 Columbia Law Review article. “Largely supported by organizations like the National Rifle Association” in the 1980s, Ms. Phillips writes, “almost all states now preempt local gun regulation.” In the first quarter of 2017, roughly 20 states introduced preemption bills prohibiting local employment regulations in a reaction to cities raising the minimum wage and mandating paid sick leave. Specifically, she cites an Ohio preemption law banning local governments from moving the needle on minimum wage just six months before Cleveland was to hold a public vote on the issue. According to local reports Thursday, the Ohio state Legislature has already introduced a bill that would preempt any local bans on plastic bags. Arguments for city influence Activists and elected officials point to growing urban centers as justification for a larger role in American, and global, decision-making. The U.N. predicts 68% of the world population will live in urban areas by 2050. Immigration and environment are existential issues, city advocates say. “Defending our borders, issues of citizenship and so forth are clearly federal responsibilities,” Mr. Dougherty said. “However, the way the federal government has dealt with it creates a lot of local problems.” Cities for Action, a coalition of 175 cities — to which Mr. Peduto’s name is signed — advocates for pro-immigrant federal policies and ways to manage immigration at the local level, including civics education and municipal ID programs. While they’re some of the biggest economic engines, cities also have the biggest carbon footprints. “Our studies show that about 70% of greenhouse gas emissions can be attributed to cities,” said David Miller, former Toronto mayor and North American director for C40, a network of cities committed to reducing emissions. “If cities control those levers, their action can make a direct impact.” Municipal governments often have direct control over buildings, transportation and solid waste, he said. “I just came from Tokyo where a group of cities were meeting to present on the positions the G20 should be taking to help solve issues of climate and equality,” Mr. Miller said. “That wouldn’t have been possible 20 years ago.” Those possibilities are why Pittsburgh City Councilwoman Strassburger said she’s in the camp of cities “being a hotbed of innovation.” “There’s a lot to be learned by pushing boundaries at the local level,” she said.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.