Taxing weed just preserves the black market---wouldn’t raise revenue
Kevin Sabet 13, Director of the Drug Policy Institute and Assistant Professor in the Division of Addiction Medicine, University of Florida; Ph.D., Social Policy, Oxford University (Marshall Scholar); Senior Policy Advisor in the Obama Administration's Office of National Drug Control Policy, 2009-2011; co-founder, with Patrick J. Kennedy, of Project SAM (Smart Approaches to Marijuana). “Article: A New Direction? Yes. Legalization? No. Drawing on Evidence to Determine Where to Go in Drug Policy,” 91 Or. L. Rev. 1153
II Public Budgets Will Suffer, Not Gain, from Drug Legalization and Taxation Many legalization advocates urge the government to "tax the hell out of" drugs, 14 in order to pay for the assumed increased use and addiction costs. That way, new users will be deterred from starting because the price would be out of reach. The most vulnerable (i.e. the poor) would benefit from high costs, too, since one might think that those with less disposable income can afford expensive drugs. Ironically, however, this scenario actually exacerbates some of the worst qualities of prohibition. High-cost drugs would ensure that an already well-established black market would remain largely in tact. If a person can buy cocaine for ten dollars an ounce from a dealer or go to a government-sponsored "drug store" for ten times that much, he or she would opt for the former scenario. Especially if drugs were still illegal for minors (no one has seriously proposed legalizing marijuana or cocaine for minors), a black market would still have reasons to linger. This is precisely what occurred in Canada when it imposed steep taxes on cigarettes. 15 In fact, today there is a thriving black market for the highly taxed cigarettes in certain parts of the United States as criminals smuggle packs of cigarettes from lower-taxed states to those with higher taxes. For example, New York has the highest tax on cigarettes in the country ($ 4.35 per pack, with an additional $ 1.50 in New York City). 16 As a result, it has the highest [*1158] smuggling rates in the United States: 60.9% of cigarettes were smuggled into New York in 2011. 17 After Massachusetts, Florida, and Utah raised their cigarette taxes, smuggling significantly increased. 18 California Board of Equalization officials have recently estimated that cigarette excise tax revenue evasion was $ 182 million in fiscal year 2005-06. 19 Around fifteen percent of all cigarettes sold in that state have somehow avoided the excise taxes in place on each pack to raise revenues for the state budget. 20 This is lower than evasion rates in other countries, according to the Chief Economist for the California Board of Equalization. 21 For example, about twenty-two percent of the United Kingdom's domestic cigarette market now consists of smuggled cigarettes. 22 In Canada, smuggled cigarettes represented about thirty-three percent of all domestic cigarette consumption at their peak. 23 In the United States, illegal drugs cost $ 193 billion per year in lost social costs. 24 That number would no doubt increase under legalization and then have to be distributed to the new number of total drug users. Experience with taxing alcohol and tobacco shows that any attempt to pay for lost costs through taxes would be futile. Indeed the social costs of legalization (e.g., increased health costs, accidents, productivity losses) outweigh any possible tax that could be levied against the drug. Drugs that are already legal in the United States are a good example of what would happen if we thought we could reap the financial benefits of illegal drugs: For every one dollar of revenue they produce, they each cost the United States ten dollars in lost social costs. 25