Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

C/I – Fiscal redistribution is the ratio of tax burden to received government benefits---increasing redistribution can be achieved by changing either tax or spending policy alone

Andrew Chamberlain 7, Staff Economist, Tax Foundation; Gerald Prante, Staff Economist, Tax Foundation; and Scott A. Hodge, President, Tax Foundation, March 2007, “Who Pays America’s Tax Burden, and Who Gets the Most Government Spending?,” https://files.taxfoundation.org/legacy/docs/sr151.pdf

VII. Putting Tax Burdens and Government Spending Together: Net Tax Burdens

Now that we’ve looked at both the nation’s tax burden and government spending, let’s put them both together. When we do this, we end up with a measure of how much people pay into government, and how much government spends on to people in return. Economists sometimes refer to this as “fiscal redistribution” or the “fiscal incidence” of government policy.

Figure 6 compares household tax burdens to the amount of government spending received by Americans. It answers the following question: “For every dollar of taxes paid, how much government spending is targeted at households in return?” As is clear from the figure, when government spending is considered along with tax burdens, the overall picture of the fairness of government policy is dramatically different from the usual picture of tax burdens alone.

Some households clearly benefit much more from current tax and spending policy on a dollar-for-dollar basis than others. Overall, households in the bottom three quintiles are net beneficiaries from tax and spending policies. They received more than one dollar of government spending for every dollar of taxes they paid in 2004. In contrast, households in the top two quintiles are net fiscal payers, receiving less than one dollar of government spending for every tax dollar paid to governments.

When all government spending is included, households in the lowest quintile received about $8.21 in spending for every dollar of taxes paid. Households in the middle quintile received $1.30, and households in the top quintile received $0.41.

At the federal level, government spending and taxes are much more unevenly distributed than at the state and local level. America’s bottom income group received $14.76 of federal spending for every dollar of taxes they send to Washington, compared to $1.29 for the middle quintile and just $0.32 for America’s highest earners. State and local public finances also provide substantial benefits to lower-income households, but not to the same degree. The bottom income group received $4.03 in state and local spending per dollar of state and local taxes, while households in middle quintile received $1.33 and households in the top quintile received $0.61.

The spending amounts in Figures 4, 5 and 6 include all federal, state and local government spending. However, some kinds of government spending really benefit all households equally, and aren’t targeted specifically at certain people. Economists call these things “public goods.” For example, spending on national defense, environmental protection and criminal justice are supplied to all American households equally by lawmakers. As a result, it’s sometimes useful to leave out those spending programs and see how the distribution of tax burdens and government spending changes.10

In 2004, total spending on “public goods” like national defense and environmental protection was about $8,150 per household—$6,059 in federal spending and $2,090 in state and local spending. Table 4 shows what the numbers from Figure 6 look like when spending on “public goods” that benefit every household equally are left out. As is clear from the table, leaving out spending on public goods does not significantly change the overall pattern. Some taxpayers still come out further ahead than others.

Another way to compare tax burdens with government spending is to add up all the spending people receive, and subtract off the taxes they pay. This gives a measure of peoples’ “net tax burden,” or the amount they pay or receive from government once all taxes and spending are counted.

Figure 7 shows the total dollars of government spending households receive in each quintile, minus the taxes they pay. Overall, the bottom three income quintiles receive more dollars of government spending than they pay in taxes. Households in the lowest-earning quintile receive about $31,185 more in total spending than they pay in taxes, while households in the middle quintile receive $6,424 more in spending than taxes.

In contrast, households in the fourth quintile pay $8,091 more in taxes than they receive in government spending. Households in the top quintile receive the least spending compared to tax burdens, paying $48,449 more in taxes on average than they get back in government spending.

When the totals from Figure 7 are summed into an aggregate for the U.S. economy, households in the top two quintiles paid roughly $1.03 trillion more in total taxes than they received in government spending. In contrast, households in the bottom three quintiles received about $1.53 trillion more in government spending than they paid in taxes. The difference between the two—approximately $496 billion—represents how much more government spent than it collected in taxes in 2004.

Depending on what assumption we make about who gets the benefits of this deficit spending—that is, whether we assume it goes to those with upper-incomes, those with middle incomes, or those with low incomes—governments at all levels redistributed somewhere between $1 trillion and $1.5 trillion through government tax and spending policies in 2004.

VIII. Implications for Public Policy

As we’ve seen above, government taxes and spending redistribute between $1 trillion and $1.5 trillion between the five quintiles of household income each year. This fact is not apparent by looking at the tax system alone. For this reason, it’s important for Americans to look beyond the distribution of only taxes and start counting government spending received as well. Only by counting both can we give an accurate judgment about what government policies are doing for different income groups in America.

A New Way Forward on Tax Reform

Once we realize taxes and spending are two sides of the same coin, new ways to achieve better tax policy for America become possible. By mixing together tax and spending policies, the classic trade-off between “efficiency” and “equity” disappears in many cases, allowing us to improve the economy by phasing-out inefficient taxes without taking away the advantages we’ve already conferred on America’s lowest-income households.

For example, many lawmakers favor sharply progressive taxes—that is, they favor taxes that fall more heavily on high earners than those with low incomes. These lawmakers usually oppose any tax reform plan that cuts the level of tax progressivity—such as a single-rate income tax or a retail sales tax—despite the economic benefits of those tax reforms.

But once we see that tax progressivity is only half the picture, and that progressivity can be achieved through either taxes or spending, these lawmakers’ opposition to economically efficient tax reforms no longer makes sense. Any amount of progressivity can be achieved by some mix of tax and spending changes. That means it’s possible to move toward a flatter, more economically neutral tax code, without reducing the progressivity in the fiscal system.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.