US engaged in competition with China- only a focus on maintaining competitive edge ensures continued hegemony
Martijn Rasser and Megan Lamberth in 2021
Former Senior Fellow and Director, Technology and National Security Program and Former Associate Fellow, Technology and National Security Program; Taking the Helm
A National Technology Strategy to Meet the China Challenge; Center for a New American Security; https://www.cnas.org/publications/reports/taking-the-helm-a-national-technology-strategy-to-meet-the-china-challenge
America’s technology dominance is waning as a result. While China has developed and implemented long-term national strategies for technological competitiveness, the U.S. approach has been far more reactive and disjointed. The rivalry between the United States and China in 5G wireless is emblematic in many ways of the technology competition between the two countries. The Chinese government was preparing for 5G years before the United States, championing the Chinese firm Huawei, which clinched outsized global market share and threatened the integrity and independence of U.S. allies’ 5G networks and associated critical infrastructure.16 While China’s competitive edge in 5G was a wake-up call for U.S. policymakers, the scale of the challenge is much greater. U.S. technological leadership is at a critical juncture. China represents a dynamic and fast-growing challenge to American global technological leadership. China is no longer a nation of copying but is engaging in true innovation and is a serious technological competitor. In a number of critical technology areas—AI, quantum sciences, biotechnology—China is at a position of rough parity or has surpassed the United States.17 China’s desire to be a “science and technology superpower” is driven by a number of national strategies—Made in China 2025, Belt and Road Initiative, China Standards 2035, strategy on military-civil fusion, among others.18 Under these umbrella strategies, China has implemented sector-specific approaches, such as the New Generation Artificial Intelligence Development Plan or the country’s National Laboratory for Quantum Information Science.19 The United States has no equivalent to China’s national approach.20 The Trump administration’s National Strategy for Critical and Emerging Technologies (October 2020) attempts to fill this void; however, it lacks implementation guidance and enforcement mechanisms.21 The United States also has a number of technology-specific strategies, such as Maintaining American Leadership in Artificial Intelligence (February 2019), the National Quantum Initiative Act (December 2018), and the National Strategy to Secure 5G (March 2020), but these disparate strategies lack an overarching approach to tie them together.22 Congress, meanwhile, is debating a range of ambitious legislative proposals that would offer tens of billions in funding for a range of foundational and emerging technologies.23 While well-intended, there is no coherent strategic framework to tie these assorted efforts together. The U.S. government’s response to China’s digital authoritarianism and illicit economic practices has similarly been disjointed. The U.S. government has countered China’s actions—intellectual property (IP) theft, forced technology transfer, and commercial and academic espionage—through existing tools of economic statecraft. The use of these powerful and effective tools—export controls, enhanced investment screening, and targeted sanctions—must be guided by a consistent, repeatable approach. The United States cannot apply a one-size-fits-all solution to counter China’s technological advancement or its anti-competitive, illicit, or undemocratic practices. Washington must, however, articulate a strategy that recognizes these challenges have the same root: the United States is engaged in a strategic competition with China and it must run faster. Running faster will require a course correction for the United States—a unified, consistent framework to guide the U.S. government’s approach to key technology policy areas.