US competitiveness is the key internal link to hegemony- it maintains the necessary industrial base and bolsters US image abroad
Hughes in 21
Kent, Public Policy Fellow and Chief Economic and International Trade Advisor in the Office of the Director, CEO and President of the Woodrow Wilson International Center for Scholars; The New Economy and U.S. Global Competitiveness; https://www.kas.de/documents/283221/283270/The+New+Economy+and+US+Global+Competitiveness.pdf/89a84838-1ab7-1310-6977-095ccce95521?version=1.0&t=1615905263752
Where once the United States was the dominant economic power, now that global stage is shared by Europe, East and South Asia, and China. There are important economies on every continent. Where once America seemed home to innovations, now one also needs to look around the world for new ideas, new cures, and new products. With the collapse of the Soviet Union and the economic challenges of German reunification and the Japanese financial crisis, suddenly the United States stood alone as an unrivaled superpower. In 1992, Francis Fukuyama published his End of History and the Last Man. By the end of history, Fukuyama is widely interpreted as saying that democratic capitalism remained as the only path to economic growth and political organization (Fukuyama, 1992). Since that period of contented U.S. hubris, the world has taken yet another turn. China has emerged as a major economic force and presents itself as the model for growth and governance. After the turn of the century, the United States made several serious mistakes. It failed to anticipate the terrorist attacks in September 2001. The subsequent invasion of Iraq proved to be a geopolitical blunder. The global financial crisis revealed that, contrary to global expectations, the U.S. did not effectively control its complicated financial system. Finally, the United States’ muddled mismanagement of the Covid-19 pandemic has raised questions about America’s ability to govern effectively. China had, of course, made the initial mistakes of failing to identify the virus or acting to contain it. But when it moved into action, it proved decisive and effective. China has been quick to emphasize the contrast to the United States. Yet despite China’s rise and American mistakes, much of the world still looks for American leadership in world affairs. Much of Asia welcomes America as a military and even economic counterweight to China. Long-standing allies in Europe and Asia would welcome renewed American commitment to continued economic, political, and military ties. What should America do to Restore Its Leadership? First, it should remember how America and its allies prevailed in World War II. Second, it should recognize that while it is still a major power, the world is now made up of other established and rising powers. Third, it must listen more and talk less. Fourth, it needs to adjust its policies to the new economy and new circumstances. Finally, it needs to restore confidence in public institutions and develop a new national purpose. U.S. Leadership – Traditional Strengths The United States played a leading role in containing the Soviet Union but drew on the active support of allies around the world. In terms of direct competition, the United States out produced and out innovated the Soviet Union. The United States was active in exercising what Joseph Nye has named soft power. For many people, freedom and democracy were more attractive than authoritarian communism. Looking forward, the United States again needs to restore alliances where there are shared interests and shared values at stake. Existing allies in Europe and Asia, have similar complaints about China’s economic strategy and to authoritarian practices in China and elsewhere around the world. In responding to global crises – anticipating future pandemics to dealing with climate change to securing global supply chains – an allied effort can provide effective leadership in what must be a global response. U.S. Leadership – A Multipolar World with an Economy of Many Powers America must recognize that while it may still be the first among peers, the world is made up of many established and other rising powers. It is not 1946, or 1960, or even 2000. America’s domestic and foreign policies will have to adjust to the challenge of many competitors, some of which are geopolitical allies. The competitive landscape is made more complex by the rise of global corporations and international trading rules. Where China may rely on authoritarian rule to guide its international economic activities, the United States will need to use incentives, subsidies, joint ventures, and international agreements to fully draw on its national strengths. U.S. Leadership – Learning from the World America still has strengths and institutions that contain useful lessons for the world. America’s higher education system sets a global standard. The silicon valleys that have emerged around the country offer lessons in innovation. Americans’ tolerance for risk helps drive resilience and innovation. In American leadership nothing is more important than effectively managing the pandemic, restoring economic growth, and responding to national demands for shared prosperity and broad-based economic opportunity. Conclusion: Restoring American Leadership 32THE NEW ECONOMY AND U.S. GLOBAL COMPETITIVENESS | MARCH 2021The world also has many lessons to teach America. For instance, every industrial power in the world has universal health care. The systems vary but all cover everyone. There are several variants of capitalism found across the industrial world. The United States and Great Britain leave more to private markets. German industry has labor representatives on one of its corporate boards. Germany also has a system that links companies with technology problems to a set of applied research institutes that can turn to advanced institutes when basic research is required. Japan has a history of working closely with industry, setting national priorities, and adopting policies that drive competitiveness (Hughes, 2005, pp. 94-108). When it comes to K-12 education, America should look at the structure of education in countries that perform the best – Finland and several East Asian countries which lead the field in the international exams of science, mathematics and reading. Adapting foreign solutions to American strengths, values, and traditions will be an effective way to move through the 21st century. U.S. Leadership – New Thinking for the New Economy The U.S. can no longer cling with almost religious devotion to the idea that private markets can solve every problem. Nor can the country count on an education system tied to an agricultural calendar or one dependent on local property taxes. The U.S. needs to adjust its thinking and its actions to the many realities of the new economy. Rising economic powers, new technologies, an economy demanding new skills, the development of cyber weapons, precision guided missiles, and other changes all demand new, creative policies. The pandemic has put a spotlight on existing inequalities in terms of income, wealth, education, and access to health care. The national response to the death of Floyd George has awakened the nation to a renewed effort to create an economy that offers opportunity and a decent income to all Americans. The Biden administration is faced with growing demands to tackle major inequalities, to work toward greater inclusion, and to make progress against climate change. The Biden team seeks to make a range of domestic investments, generate jobs, adjust the military to new threats and new technologies, and forge a successful foreign policy. President Trump’s emphasis on America First contained two basic truths. Competitiveness policy and foreign policy both begin at home. Not a turning inward, but a recognition that in a democracy based on the idea of equality, persistent inequities will undermine the strength of the country.