Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Slow U.S. recovery causes China war

Bapat 20, a Professor in International Relations. He received a B.A. in Political Science from the University of Michigan in 1998 and pursued graduate studies at Rice University, where he received an M.A. (2000) and a PhD (2004) in political science. (Navin, August 19th, 2020, “Will COVID-19 Cause a War? Understanding the Case of the U.S. and China”, (https://www.degruyter.com/view/journals/peps/ahead-of-print/article-10.1515-peps-2020-0047/article-10.1515-peps-2020-0047.xml?language=en)

We therefore see that COVID-19 may cause a decline in U.S. economic power, which may undermine its military readiness and ability to support future economic gains. However, the next question is: does the PRC seek to challenge the U.S. for global primacy, and if so, why? In his speech to the Communist Party in 2017, President Xi Jinping claimed that China should now, “take center stage in the world.” A key part in of this effort is represented by Xi’s 2013 Belt and Road Initiative (OBOR), which seeks to extend the PRC’s economic, political, and cultural influence throughout south Asia to the Middle East and into Europe. The OBOR utilizes the newly created Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank (AIIB), an alternative to the World Bank, to finance infrastructure projects throughout the different regions (). From the power transition standpoint, it therefore appears that the PRC is developing a string of assets and bases extending from the Pacific through the Indian Ocean to the Persian Gulf. Numerous U.S. military planners view these developments as a deliberative effort to undermine U.S. power and influence in both the Pacific and Middle East theaters. In theoretical terms, if we accept that the OBOR represents an effort by the PRC (the rising power) to supplant the U.S., war could still be avoided if the power transition moves at a relatively slower rate. model establishes that dominant powers only initiate preemptive war if they are declining at precipitous rates. This is where COVID-19 poses a significant threat. Since the outbreak, the U.S. economy has declined by 4.8%, and the U.S. is borrowing from its future at high levels. If the PRC wanted to challenge the US for supremacy, this would be the time, and there is some evidence that the PRC is exploiting the opportunity. Beginning in May 2020, the Peoples’ Liberation Army (PLA) is engaging in repeated clashes with the Indian Armed Forces in the Ladekh region as part of a longstanding border dispute. As of July 2020, China is coming close to forming a strategic partnership with Iran. The pact would give the PRC a foothold in the Middle East, secure discounted oil, and perhaps allow for more oil trades to be settled in non-dollar denominations. This effort is in spite of significant strategic interests in the region and growing hostilities between Washington and Tehran. The greater concern is that China will use its newfound clout to accelerate its effort to take control of much of the territory in the South China Sea. China has long claimed large portions of this key area as its own, whereas Vietnam, Malaysia, the Philippines, and Brunei who all have competing claims. The US has long served as a balancer to prevent China from encroaching. However, beginning in December 2013, China constructed and later militarized artificial islands in the South China Sea to reinforce its territorial claims, despite promises not to do so. In this period, the states of Southeast Asia have typically looked to the U.S. Navy to challenge China’s claims. It has done so through Freedom of Navigation exercises. However, now, with COVID-19, the Navy’s capabilities are in doubt. Interestingly, most analysts conclude that China is not exploiting the opportunity in the area. Instead, the PRC’s efforts to build and fortify their islands continue at the previous rate, indicating “business as usual.”Nonetheless, the U.S. seems concerned about the possibility that China will seek to exploit the opportunity created by COVID-19. The Trump administration is therefore sending three carrier strike groups, with a large influx of naval vessels, into the area to re-assert American control of the seas. Although this increases U.S. capability, it also signals weakness, in that the U.S. would not need to take such dramatic steps unless it faced a significant challenge. While it does not appear that the US is ready to initiate a preemptive challenge here, this increased militarization raises the possibility of accidents, which in turn does increase the probability of conflict. Empirically, military mobilizations such as these raise the possibility of accidents that may trigger militarized interstate disputes, or military crises short of war (). Theoretically, military mobilizations may temporarily increase a state’s power, but this increase may be unsustainable given the increasing cost of putting armed forces in theater. This creates a dynamic where a state that has mobilized may be forced to use its weapons before it is compelled to redeploy them (Slantchev 2005; Tarar 2013). 3 COVID-19’s Long Term Threat These observations lead to several conclusions about the immediate security situation. COVID-19 seems to have cost the U.S. some of its military capability relative to China. This may encourage China to push the U.S. while it is weak, and conversely, may compel the U.S. to mobilize to counter this threat. Since each of these activities is a response to the economic shock of COVID-19, we can see that the virus has increased the likelihood of a militarized encounter between the U.S. and China. However, it is important to recognize that even if China were to succeed in all of its military challenges to the U.S., this alone would not shift hegemony from the U.S. The key reason for this is that the majority of economic actors in the world seem to view the USD as the key reserve currency, and at this point, the RMB is not in a position to challenge that status (Norrlof et al. 2020; Oatley et al. 2013; Poast 2015). Despite significant criticism of the Trump administration during the economic shock of COVID-19, much of the world seems to view Federal Reserve Chairman Jerome Powell as a critical and stable player in international monetary policy. Powell indicated that the U.S. will continue to support global growth by keeping U.S. interest rates low. This allows for more money to be available for the rest of the world. Indirectly, this move may make China more powerful by encouraging investments in their market. However, this is also keeping the world tied to the dollar based system, which is the key component of American power. So long as the rest of the world continues to rely on USD as the means to settle transactions, and so long as the PRC’s market seems less transparent and stable, the US will continue to maintain its position of power in the international system. However, this is based on the assumption that the US will be able to recover whatever power it has temporarily lost due to COVID-19. There are a few reasons to call this assumption into question. First, the US right now is the global epicenter of the COVID-19 crisis, despite its economic power and large medical infrastructure. This is largely attributed to a poor political response, which is causing the virus to spread at a much faster rate than in other states. As a result, the US now finds itself facing travel restrictions from numerous countries. This may give other states less reason to engage in economic transactions with Americans. These lost exchanges will likely be replaced by interacting with other citizens throughout the globe, and will therefore be settled in non-dollar denominations. The more this occurs, the more demand for USD could decline into the future. The US could potentially find itself increasing isolated with fewer individuals demanding its currency. Should this occur, the ability of the US to finance its budgets through deficit spending will decrease, and it will need to raise taxes and cut spending. Some of this will likely be on defense, which means that the ability of the US to defend interests in the Pacific and the Middle East will decline, opening the door for China. Even worse, the political rhetoric inside the US is encouraging these changes. President Trump’s foreign policy platform is described as “American First”, which represents a combination of isolationism and unilateralism, and a general rejection of multilateral cooperation. If that is the case, each state in the international system will need to begin planning to move away from the American backed system. The damage done by COVID-19 to the US market, and the weakening of the US position as a result of the virus, will accelerate this process. These changes will not happen overnight, and will not happen so quickly that a rapid transition will occur. This means that it is unlikely that COVID-19 will increase the risk of general war between the US and China, though it does raise the risk of crises and limited encounters. However, over the long term, if the US is unable to get the virus under control and develop a plan of action, COVID-19 does pose significant threats to US military and economic hegemony.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.