Jobs guarantee structurally solves inequality- addresses wages and labor power
Pavlina R. Tcherneva in 2023
Ph.D., is an Associate Professor of Economics at Bard College, the Director of OSUN’s Economic Democracy Initiative, and a Research Scholar at the Levy Economics Institute, NY. She specializes in monetary and fiscal policy coordination and employment policy., The Job Guarantee: MMT's Proposal for Full Employment and Price Stability, Working Paper Series Open Society University Network Economic Democracy Initiative
To sum up, while the Federal Reserve has no reliable theory of inflation or the NAIRU, it nevertheless insists on forfeiting jobs for price stability. By contrast, MMT argues that public policy has both the responsibility and the ability to achieve and maintain both. Only the currency issuer can institute and implement automatic anticyclical economic stabilizers, including an employment stabilizer. This is the macroeconomic function of the Job Guarantee. It is worth pointing out that, while this specific Job Guarantee framework emerges from an understanding of the unique currency-issuing powers of the state, as a real-world policy solution, the Job Guarantee is also available to nations that do not issue or control their currencies. This is because they too will continue to face the outsized costs of unemployment. Whatever the monetary system, the public sector is responsible for the unemployed; it bears the unavoidable real and financial costs of unemployment and related social problems. In a certain sense, paying for poverty and unemployment is already baked into government budgets and the Job Guarantee, as will be discussed below, is a superior policy method for eliminating them compared to conventional methods. A non-sovereign monetary system, however, may face obstacles to achieving and maintaining tight long-run full employment, because the policy space available to do so is smaller than that of monetarily sovereign nations. The above discussion highlights a core MMT claim: unemployment is a public sector failure that only the state can remedy. While unemployment is reproduced in multiple ways, in all cases, it is a situation when someone is willing to work for currency, a demand that only the issuer can ultimately 6 choke off. From here, it follows that the private sector cannot provide employment to all, not only because it runs against the logic of the profit motive, but also because the private sector does not have (and is unwilling to part with) the very means to employ the unemployed (currency), precisely at a time when the problem of unemployed is most acute (in downturns). Furthermore, the logic of the private sector is to minimize its cost of production, including labor costs. Therefore, providing jobs for all who need them is inherently outside the purview of private sector activity. To put it directly, firms are not in the business of hiring every job seeker who comes a knocking. A STRUCTURAL POLICY, NOT JUST A JOBS PROGRAM The Job Guarantee is a structural macroeconomic policy that secures full employment and price stability, while addressing the inequities already embedded in the labor market, including the large social and economic costs of unemployment. It is important to make the case for the Job Guarantee, even if the NAIRU were abandoned as a policy guide, because the convention (even among laborfriendly economists) is to define ‘full employment’ as some positive level of involuntary unemployment. This is because conventional policy approaches simply cannot deliver jobs for all.6 And, even when they aim for low levels of unemployment, they continue to work through the highly-unequal existing labor market mechanisms. The Job Guarantee is a game-changer for the economy and the most vulnerable workers. It is well understood that official statistics do not capture the true levels of unemployment – especially those experienced by people of color, with disabilities, caregivers, veterans, or in regions of ongoing economic distress. Indeed, the labor market is not a fair game and structural inequities in hiring are exacerbated by the fact that there are not enough employment opportunities for all. As the COIVID experience showed (Cajner et al. 2020), job losses are not experienced equally either: the lower the wage – the higher the job losses and the slower the recovery in lost payrolls. This is true for garden-variety recessions too. Job losses among low wage workers, who have the least capacity (savings or other assets) to weather a recession, occur earlier, longer and are proportionately greater than those for people at the high end of the income distribution (Tcherneva 2012). The perennial threat of unemployment is a powerful force of reproducing inequities in the labor market, denying certain workers employment opportunities, eroding wages and benefits for those who work, and growing the precariat. The Job Guarantee helps secure decent employment for all, and especially for the most disenfranchised groups and people facing systemic barriers to employment.