Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI doesn’t address the root cause of poverty and inequality – only the alt can provide the necessary class analysis in order to improve material socio-economic conditions

Cope ’19 (Dylan Cope, , 8-15-2019, "Universal Basic Income," https://socialist.net/universal-basic-income-is-it-the-radical-change-we-need/) -- MG

But whilst a UBI could in theory provide a safety net for the most vulnerable, the fact remains that the proposal is still only a mild form of redistribution. At root, it does nothing to challenge the unchecked power, property, and profits of the billionaire class. Any UBI money handed out, after all, would simply end up flowing upwards into the pockets of the parasites and profiteers. In the final analysis, a UBI system would ultimately maintain the broken status quo of the profit motive and the anarchy of the market, doing nothing to stop the chaotic crises of capitalism that have caused unemployment and cuts to social services in the first place. Right-wing support Indeed, UBI is not an idea unique to the left. In fact, many conservative and libertarian thinkers see UBI as a golden opportunity. One of the earliest proponents of a similar proposal, for example, was none other than Milton Friedman, a key economic advisor to Thatcher. The right-wing argument is that if everyone has a guaranteed income, there would be no need for public services that are free at the point of use, such as the NHS. This individualist outlook would mean people could opt into the services they wanted and not have to pay for services they didn’t use. For example, why should they pay for children’s education if they don’t have a child? Why should they financially support cancer treatments if they do not have cancer? In short, the aim of these right-wingers is to use UBI to get rid of the welfare state and unleash the market into every sphere of human life. This is at a time when even the UN have recently produced a report stating that: “much of the glue that has held British society together since the Second World War has been deliberately removed and replaced with a harsh and uncaring ethos.” UBI is also attractive to big business owners as yet another way for the state to subsidise the low wages currently offered by the bosses; as another method by which the capitalists can continue suppressing workers’ wages and boosting profits, all the while offloading the social burden onto the rest of society. Get to the roots This again shows how UBI does not challenge the fundamental problem at the heart of the matter: the question of economic ownership. Inequality is only the symptom – capitalism is the disease. It is the capitalists’ private ownership over the economy that causes such massive inequality within society, with an accumulation of profits at the top, and an accumulation of poverty amongst the rest. It is therefore wrong to call UBI a ‘radical change’. Marx said that to be radical is to grasp the root of the matter. And the root of poverty, inequality, and all social ills is precisely the capitalist system, based on private ownership, competition, and production for profit. By merely tinkering with how society’s wealth is distributed, UBI does nothing to get to the actual cause of the problem. As any gardener will attest, if you do not tackle the root then the weeds will continue to return!

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.