Fiscal Redistribution including basic income under the current system fails to address inequality effectively and leads to hyper-capitalism
Jackson & Victor 21 – [Tim Jackson, Centre for the Understanding of Sustainable Prosperity, University of Surrey, and Peter Victor, Faculty of Environmental Studies, York University, "Confronting inequality in the “new normal”: Hyper‐capitalism, proto‐socialism, and post‐pandemic recovery," PubMed Central, 05-04-2021, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC8242820/] /jsam
The two key structural factors, which determine the evolution of inequality under a declining growth rate, are (1) the savings rate and (2) the elasticity of substitution between labor and capital. Depending on the configuration of these factors, two radically different futures may emerge. Under one future, which we have described here as “hyper‐capitalism” (Scenario 1), a constant savings rate and high substitutability between capital and labor lead to accelerating inequality, even under a progressive combination of redistributive measures. Under another kind of future, which we describe as proto‐socialism (Scenario 2), a declining savings rate and low substitutability between capital and labor, lead to declining inequality, which in combination with progressive redistributive policies, have the potential to eliminate inequality almost completely. Turning next to redistributive policies, the most striking finding from our model is that even relatively progressive policies, which impose a combination of higher differential tax rates, taxes on capital and a basic income (funded from returns to capital) remain ineffective in the long run in bringing down structural inequality under the hyper‐capitalism described in Scenario 1. Higher capital to income rates, constant savings rates, and the rigorous protection of rates of return on investment lead inevitably to the “explosive” inequality highlighted by Piketty, and the best efforts of progressive fiscal policies are unlikely to be able to halt this rise. Even the much vaunted “solution” of a basic income fails to curb the inevitable rise in inequality under such conditions (Scenario 1). In the “proto‐socialism” of Scenario 2, on the other hand, this same combination of measures is strikingly effective. By the end of the run (Figure (Figure7),7), inequality between capitalists and workers is almost entirely eliminated. Hyper‐capitalism is likely to emerge in a world where labor is increasingly (and easily) substituted with capital and the interests of the owners of capital are privileged over the rights of workers. These privileges encourage capitalists to continue to save even as the growth rate declines, leading to a rising capital to output ratio and an escalating inequality. Such a scenario could, for example, accompany a world in which an aggressive drive towards automation or the implementation of artificial intelligence (AI) by monopolistic companies removes the need for wage labor across large swathes of the economy. Failure to protect the livelihoods of the immiserated work force facilitates continued savings and investment by asset owners. By the same token, it concentrates incomes (and wealth) increasingly in a minority of the population, leading to the kinds of dystopian trends in inequality illustrated in Scenario 1. 13