Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

UBI will not only perpetuate current capitalism but deepens the effect towards authoritarianism.

Frost 6-8 [David, “Universal basic income would put us on the road to authoritarianism”; 6-8-2023, Telegraph, https://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2023/06/08/marxism-winning-as-welfare-for-all-becomes-mainstream/; JFan]

The latest twist on this idea comes from Silicon Valley. People like Elon Musk and Sir Tim Berners-Lee claim that soon AI will be so capable that it will be able to do virtually everyone’s job. They seem to take Marx’s original view, that capitalism will in the end leave a few people holding all the wealth and the workers will be immiserated – and so believe that only a UBI will give people the income they need in this new world of leisure. Of course it never works out like that. People have always said this about technological advances and they have always been wrong. New technology generates new jobs rather than kills them. But the UBI advocates will turn any argument to their cause. Left-wingers always think clever people can remodel society and that we are all just one new idea away from nirvana. As we know, that never works out well either. It doesn’t stop them trying. So now we have a plan for a trial scheme from Autonomy, an “independent, progressive research organisation”, for 30 people to be paid £1,600 a month for two years, with their lives monitored and compared with 30 people who must work for a living. (In fact it’s not the first trial: as so often with bad ideas, the Welsh “Government” got there first, with its own plan beginning next month.) The Autonomy trial is obviously laughable. Giving 30 people money for nothing for two years is hardly going to tell you anything useful. But it keeps the issue in the public eye. Bit by bit the Overton window, the range of politically possible ideas, is moving to accommodate it. UBI was always a marginal idea until recently. But unfortunately Covid collectivism and “sustainability” lifestyle lecturing have made all too many of us prey to the economic snake oil advocates. UBI is gradually moving from the fringe to the mainstream of Left-wing politics, at least if we assume that mainstream includes Andy Burnham, who has said he’d like to try it out in Manchester. So we need to rubbish it while we still can. The clearest argument against a UBI is that it makes no economic sense. Pay the income in the Autonomy trial to everyone of working age in Britain and it would cost about £700 billion a year. For comparison, last year all existing taxes and other receipts raised just over £900  billion, and the Government spent £1,040 billion. So, if nothing else changed, a UBI at this low level would nearly double the tax burden, and the government would spend something like three quarters of all the money in the country. That way madness lies. Taxes at that level would comfortably be the highest in the world and anyone who could leave would do so. Output would fall dramatically. Many would choose not to work more than they had to, relying on their UBI instead, so we would probably have to introduce some sort of compulsion to work. At that point we would be a super-corporatist, authoritarian quasi-fascist society – a country where private companies formally existed but everyone’s aims and aspirations would be subordinated to the government’s need, somehow, to keep the show on the road. Anyone who thinks such a society would not have social conflict or that people would be happier in it must be totally self-deluding.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.