Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Expansion of social insurance exploits efficiency to reduce the burden of the wealthy and prevent uprising from the working class

Gonzalez and Wen 14 (Franciso, PhD in Economics from Boston University, Jean Francois, PhD at Queen’s University, The Economic Journal, “A THEORY OF TOP INCOME TAXATION AND SOCIAL INSURANCE”, https://doi.org/10.1111/ecoj.12126 - SH)

5. Conclusions The advice given to the Prince of Salina in The Leopard — Giuseppe di Lampedusa’s famous portrayal of sociopolitical upheaval in nineteenth-century Italy — is: ‘If we want things to stay as they are, things will have to change’. In the same spirit, we have argued that, in the US, UK and Sweden, the wealthy responded to the threat of unrest brought about by the Great Depression by bearing a remarkable increase in top income taxation in the period 1930–60. But as new social insurance programmes and extensions of existing programmes targeted heterogeneous risks more finely over time, less redistribution through the tax system was required to avert social unrest. By 1990, programmes covered the major categories of risk faced by most households and transfers stabilised. Our main conclusion is that the development of the welfare state reflected the gradual substitution of social insurance for top income taxation as an efficient means of averting social conflict. We have abstracted from the roles commonly assigned to economic development and negative incentive effects in explaining the sources and the limits of the welfare state. We have shut down these effects to focus on the supply of social insurance and the role of economic risks. This reflects an important contrast between our view and one that equates a larger welfare state with larger efficiency losses. Instead, we see the growth in the number and complexity of transfer programmes as reflecting the exploitation of further efficiency gains. Our analysis has taken as given the pre-tax income distribution to focus on social policy. Conversely, analyses of the dynamics of the income distribution, particularly the top incomes, usually take social policy as given. We think that there are important insights to be gained from a better understanding of the joint evolution of the income distribution and social policy.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.