Social Security expansion is empirically used to further industry goals and prevent class conflict and full redistribution through concessions
Gonzalez and Wen 14 (Franciso, PhD in Economics from Boston University, Jean Francois, PhD at Queen’s University, The Economic Journal, “A THEORY OF TOP INCOME TAXATION AND SOCIAL INSURANCE”, https://doi.org/10.1111/ecoj.12126 - SH)
The Social Security Act of 1935 marks the birth of the welfare state in the US. It provided federal benefits to retirees and grants to states for the unemployed, old-age assistance, aid to dependent children, vocational rehabilitation, maternal and child welfare, and public health work.16 The New Deal programmes were legislated as social insurance to combat economic insecurity, with an emphasis on the fact that ‘funds for the payment of insurance benefits should not come from the proceeds of general taxation’ (President Roosevelt’s message to Congress on Social Security, January 17, 1935). However, they were accompanied by sharp rises in tax progressivity.17 Our interpretation is that the need for redistribution as an accompaniment to social insurance to avert social conflict was recognised at the time. Thus, while advocating the introduction of an inheritance tax, President Roosevelt stated: ‘Social unrest and a deepening sense of unfairness are dangers to our national life which we must minimize by vigorous methods’ (message to Congress on Tax Revision, June 19, 1935). He noted further that ‘The movement toward progressive taxation of wealth and of income has accompanied the growing diversification and interrelation of effort which marks our industrial society’. These comments point to the use of progressive taxation for securing industrial co-operation during the Great Depression. Domhoff (1990, 1996) discusses the identity of the power elite and the channels through which they exert their power, while Dal Bo et al. (2009) provide evidence of the remarkable persistence of political dynasties in the US.18 The important role of elites in the adoption of the 1935 Act has been stressed by Domhoff and also by Quadagno (1984, p. 645), who remarks that ‘[I]t is also important to explain why a piece of legislation with such a high level of ‘class content’, that is, a social-welfare measure, was implemented with almost no working-class input’.19 Alston and Ferrie (1993) observe that Southern large plantation owners formed a major segment of the US governing group for a century preceding 1970, operating through overwhelming Congressional committee control by the Democrats. The rural elite’s political objectives were to maintain low wages and to secure federal agricultural subsidies for large plantations. The Southern landowners ensured that the unemployment insurance component of the 1935 Act excluded farm workers and that public assistance programmes were administered by the states rather than the federal government. Alston and Ferrie also note that farm mechanisation in the 1950s significantly reduced the need for plantation workers and that it was increasingly in the interest of Southern landowners to promote the out-migration of blacks to Northern states. Thus, commenting on the Economic Opportunity Act, which was the centrepiece of the Johnson Administration’s War on Poverty, they argue that ‘it is extremely unlikely that the welfare state programmes of the 1960’s could have emerged from Congress without the countenance of Southern Congressmen’. The development of the welfare state since the Great Depression has been one of enlargement of insurable events and gradual extensions of eligibility to include more groups of individuals. The original Social Security Act excluded numerous job categories encompassing about half the working population. Coverage was added for various workers in subsequent decades. The 1950 Social Security amendments extended the old-age and survivors insurance programmes to about 10 million more persons. Self-employed farmers, homeworkers, and some self-employed professionals were added in 1954. The inclusion of disability benefits into the Social Security Act in 1956 is an example of an increase in transfers resulting from an enlargement of insurable events. The 1960 Social Security amendments increased federal grants to states to provide medical care for aged people receiving social assistance. Medicare and Medicaid were established in 1965. Old Age Insurance paid benefits to 16% of the aged in 1950, but to 92% by 1978 (Lampman, 1984).20 The total tax burden imposed by federal taxation has been approximately constant as a proportion of GDP from 1953 onwards but the composition has changed substantially.21 Social insurance contributions have risen steadily since 1950 while corporation income taxes have fallen by a similar magnitude beginning in 1953 (see Table 2.3 in the Budget of the United States, 2005). As payroll taxes are regressive and the corporation income tax is progressive, the replacement of corporate taxes with payroll taxes in federal receipts contributed to the decline in tax progressivity. Piketty and Saez (2007) find that the average federal tax rate, including individual, corporate, payroll and estate taxes, for the top 0.01% of the income distribution declined from 71.4% in 1960 to 59.3% in 1980, whereas corresponding rates faced by income groups between the 40th and the 95th percentiles were higher in 1980 than they were in 1960. Our interpretation of this decline in top income taxation is that a gradual lifting of supply-side constraints enabled more comprehensive social insurance coverage and, consequently, reduced the need for redistribution. Learning-by-doing and technical improvements in the administration of programmes and taxes played an important role in expanding coverage and lowering the cost of tax compliance. The payroll tax in the Social Security Act, for example, was a precursor to the general withholding tax on wages introduced in 1943. Quoting from US Senate Hearings, (1942, p. 136): ‘All of the employers have had 7 years’ experience [and] they will be in a much better position to do this job than they were to do the social security job back in 1936 when it first went into effect’.22 Furthermore, advances in record-keeping technology, especially automated data processing that originated during the Second World War are likely to have facilitated the extensions of social insurance programmes in the US in the 1960s and the 1970s.23