Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

M4A is a hail marry in hopes of preserving for-profit healthcare – M4A and all its contemporaries are little more than Neoliberal philanthropy.

Sculos, 19, (Bryant William Sculos 2019 "It's Capitalism, Stupid!: The Theoretical and Political Limitations of the Concept of Neoliberalism," https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/classracecorporatepower/vol7/iss2/7) #Gay Frog

That neoliberalism, at its most conceptually-valuable, is a matter of degree can be understood by looking at the on-going debate over health care in the US (though the logic can be applied in any context). There are three policies, which are each, to varying degrees, part of a neoliberalization process. This is where neoliberalism can connect to the problematic discussions and categorizations of someone like Barack Obama. We have the Affordable Care Act, or “Obamacare,” wherein the government mandates that individual citizens buy health care from private companies. This individual mandate leaves the roots of the American healthcare system in the market, and even forces citizens into that market to the benefit of private insurance companies. On the other hand, the ACA also expanded the government’s role in providing health insurance by offering citizens subsidies and offering states increased funding to expand Medicaid coverage. Thus, the ACA contains elements that contribute to neoliberalization and others that hedge against full-scale neoliberalism. Compare the ACA to the Ryan-Trump plan that was eventually withdrawn from a planned floor vote in the House of Representatives.21 This bill was a more aggressive form of neoliberalization than the ACA in that it removed the individual mandate (the penalty for violation being paid to the federal government) and replaced it with a rule allowing private insurers to charge up to 30% more for people who lacked health insurance for more than 63 days in the previous calendar year. There is still a government-allowed penalty for failing to buy insurance, but in the case of the Ryan-Trump plan the penalty money is paid directly to private companies. Additionally, while the plan retained subsidies, they were substantially more regressive than with the ACA. Another alternative bill proposed by the so-called “Freedom Caucus” of the House GOP, called for the complete repeal (without replacement) of the ACA. No subsidies to help people buy insurance. No individual mandate in any form. Insurance companies would be able to charge more or less whatever they wanted to anyone. They could discriminate based on age, gender, and pre- existing conditions. This bill is much closer to — if not fully representing — neoliberalism in its ideal form. Privatization can take many forms, but when we think about the drift towards neoliberalism, it is fundamentally a matter of degree, with few policies ever likely to fully meet the ideal-typical definition of neoliberalism sketched out above. This is where the concept of neoliberalism has value; it allows us to understand how policies as diverse as the ACA and the Freedom Caucus proposal each embody neoliberal values in distinct ways and why all degrees of neoliberalization need to be resisted. One can also put the ACA against various proposed versions of Medicare-for-All. In his earliest comments on Medicare-for-All, Bernie Sanders, considered the political father of this proposal in the popular imaginary, simply stated that Medicare-for-All means dropping the age limitation from the existing Medicare statute. However, while the existing Medicare statute is an example of a kind of single-payer (though still with co-pays and premiums, depending on the plan and the procedure), it is primarily processed through private, for-profit insurance companies, which the ability to profit off of is increasingly difficult for the public to find information about (but obviously happens or these for-profit companies wouldn’t provide Medicare plans at all). If Medicare-for-All were to proceed under the current conditions of Medicare, it would be a regression of neoliberalism and neoliberalization, without removing us from the overall structure of a capitalist political economy. If the prescription drugs are still produced and distributed within a for-profit model, if medical devices are still produced and distributed within a for-profit model, if nurses and doctors and medical workers of all kinds still produce surplus-value for for-profit health care companies, Medicare-for-All is still progress, but it does not represent moving outside of neoliberalism or neoliberalization, at least not completely, but it is certainly moving in the right direction. In other words, Medicare-for-All, in its various interactions, is a challenge to neoliberalism as neoliberalization, but it is not automatically a fundamental challenge to capitalism. Certainly, if one views Medicare-for-All as a last-ditch effort to maintain the legitimacy of for-profit health care, even through its single-payer model, it fits contradictorily within the ideological and structural-historical parameters of capitalism—and may even serve some of the forces of neoliberalization, even as it is obviously less neoliberal than the Freedom Caucus plan or the ACA. Conversely, there are other versions of Medicare-for-All that are more aggressively progressive and anti-neoliberal (though still not necessarily anti-capitalist). Sanders’ newest (2019) iteration of his Medicare-for-All plan represents the strongest left position on offer at the moment, but even this improved proposal fails to address some important aspects of the broader systemic context.22 If Medicare-for-All was provided through a publicly-controlled and managed system, without using private insurers as middlemen, and if Medicare-for-All includes negotiated prices for tests, treatments, prescription drugs, and devices, under more fully-democratic political conditions, this would appropriately be considered outside of neoliberalism and neoliberalization. It would be a complete rejection of privatization, and even some of the fundamental aspects of capitalism; health care would be less commodified and provided based on need—and while surplus-value extraction would still be a systemic component of even this expansive version of Medicare-for-All, surplus-value would be more equitably redistributed based on need and not profit-seeking. While Sanders’ new approach meets many of these criteria, it would need to be accomplished without compromise, and would likely demand deeper structural transformation in regard to how democracy works in the US (including in relation to the rest of the planet’s population). This speaks to the importance of critical engagement with campaigns such as Sanders’ in the US, and other more socialistic ones around the world, without sowing confusion or delusions in the ability of capitalism to be substantially reformed or that we can merely turn back the clock on the neoliberalization occurring within the global capitalist system without opposing capitalism (and thus neoliberalization) wholesale. These distinctions can be observed in other single-payer health care systems around the world and their distinct funding methods and degrees of privatization for different aspects of their respective health care systems.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.