Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Advocating for green tech without tackling the fundamental systemic issues merely results in another form of capitalism which strengthens the grip of capitalism and reinforces its inherent damages.

Prudham ’9 [Scott, Department of Geography and Centre for Environment, University of Toronto, Toronto, ON M5S 3G3, Canada, 1-1-2009. “Pimping Climate Change: Richard Branson, Global Warming, and the Performance of Green Capitalism.” Sage Journals. https://doi.org/10.1068/a4071; JFan]

On 21 September 2006 UK u«ber-entrepreneur and Virgin Group Chairman Richard Branson pledged approximately »1.6 billion, the equivalent of all the profits from Virgin Atlantic and Virgin Trains for the next ten years, to fighting climate change. Since then, Branson has restated his commitment to action on global warming, including investment in technologies for sequestering carbon dioxide from the atmosphere. In this paper, I critically examine and engage with Branson's announcements as a specific entre¨e into a dialog about so-called `green capitalism'. I am particularly interested in the role of the entrepreneurial subject in environmental policy and environmental action. There are glaring problems associated with green capitalism as a mash-up of environmentalism with capitalism. One of these is the tethering of environmentalism to a political economy whose mantra is growth for growth's sake, or, in Marx's terms, accumulation for accumulation's sake. This has been discussed by some as the problem of capitalism's ecological metabolism or `metabolic rift'. Yet, while accumulation for accumulation's sake may well be anathema to progressive environmentalism and sustainability, I argue that this is not only an objective, quantitative problem but also one of the qualitative dimensions of produced nature and the cultural politics of environmentalism. Appreciation of this can be gleaned by reexamining Marx's discussion of the role of the bourgeois subject in the relentless drive to reproduce and expand capital accumulation via anarchic, entrepreneurial investment. Green capitalist orthodoxy relies on this source of innovative dynamism, but in the process obscures or overlooks the fact that accumulation for accumulation's sake is by definition guided by the anarchic and amoral search for profitable realization of surplus value. Moreover, in order for green capitalism to succeed, its legitimacy must be secured. I argue that this legitimacy derives in part from specific performances of green capitalism by entrepreneurial elites, also made evident by Branson and his commitments to climate action. All of this raises questions about the political, cultural, and ecological character of green capitalism, issues brought to the fore by Branson's brand of climate activism based on his status as the quintessential post-Thatcher entrepreneur. He is a `model' post-Keynesian entrepreneurial subject in a neoliberalized economy of opportunity, particularly but by no means only iconic in the UK. Branson is thus a rare example of the business elite with a large climate footprint who has embraced action to reduce greenhouse gas emissions. But, in addition, Branson's announcements also suggest a synthesis or fusion between celebrity entrepreneurialism, on the one hand, and climate change policy, on the other. This fusion in the context of climate politics and policy is a specific thrust in the wider movement toward so-called `green capitalism': a set of responses to environmental change and environmentalism that relies on harnessing capital investment, individual choice, and entrepreneurial innovation to the green cause. No environmental challenge is now more salient, and thus no item on the green capitalism agenda is more important, than global warming. In the words of prominent green capitalism advocate and President of the Environmental Defense Fund Fred Krupp, ``We've put Earth at the brink of climate calamity, thanks to rapid industrialization and market forces. That's part one. The sequel is how we get out of this fix. I believe it's those same forces, innovation and profitöand nothing elseöthat can stop global warming'' (Griscom Little, 2008). There is every possibility that Branson's championing of action on climate change will deepen commitments to meaningful attempts to abate greenhouse gas emissions, and also bolster efforts to redress the expected impacts of climate change. This is important. Global warming and its expected impacts constitute a serious issue, with potentially catastrophic implications for the poorest people of the world (Parks and Roberts, 2006; Roberts, 2001). Nevertheless, this paper is a critique of Branson's announcements and the notion that they are somehow a `good thing'. I seek to add to an emerging critical literature on the role of cultural elites in the fight over climate change (eg Boykoff and Goodman, 2008; Gajda and Kieffer, 2007). However, my focus is specifically on the elite bourgeois subject as a subset of the phenomenon. Drawing on Branson's example, I interrogate the would-be `green capitalist' in order to elucidate some aspects of and challenges to this particular brand of elite-led action in the climate policy arena, issues that, in turn, speak to the central but somewhat overlooked role of the entrepreneurial subject in the political and cultural logic of green capitalism more broadly. The paper features two interrelated arguments. First, Branson's announcements (particularly the first one) point to a central contradiction in the green capitalist agenda. This agenda pivots in large measure on the problematic suggestion that more sustainable futures can be secured via capitalist investment and entrepreneurial innovation. Whatever truth there may be in particular cases, this obscures the relentless, restless, and growth-dependent character of capitalism's distinct metabolism, an argument most closely associated with the work of Bellamy Foster (Clark and York, 2005; Foster, 2000), but which draws in turn on Karl Marx. The metabolism critique rightfully identifies a tendency in capitalist political economies for aggregate throughput of material and energy to grow, outstripping any efficiency gains (ie the so-called `Jevons paradox'). But accumulation for accumulation's sake also entails dynamic confrontation, transformation, and redefinition of material, social, and cultural conditions in ways that confound coherent articulation of any notion of fixed `limits' (including ecological ones) to continued expansion. This essentially qualitative problem originates in the microeconomics of the entrepreneurial subject who is compelled to accumulate on an expanded scale if only to reproduce himself or herself. What results is a systemic logic of the production of new natures integrally connected to the production of space and uneven development more generally (Smith, 2008 [1984])öby the anarchic, restless drive to accumulate capital as an end in and of itself. Thus, I argue that, when thinking of capitalism's so-called `biospheric rift' (Clark and York, 2005), it is crucial to attend not only to quantities of aggregate material and energy throughput, but also to issues of quality. Secondly, focus on the elite entrepreneurial or bourgeois subject points to the need for a politico-cultural perspective on green capitalism as a sort of `drama' which must be performed. That is, the viability of green capitalism is not only an `objective' question of whether or not entrepreneurial energy, unleashed by neoliberalized green markets, can give rise to sustainable technoeconomic trajectories. Rather, it is also a political agenda whose viability turns on whether or not capitalism and environmentalism are seen subjectively to be compatible. Seen in this way, green capitalism has interwoven material semiotic dimensions (Haraway, 1997), one central facet of which is the `performance' of the entrepreneurial subject as environmental crusader. Performances such as Branson's not only stage the political and cultural fusion of capitalism and environmentalism as green capitalism; they also act to augment the economic foundations of bourgeois power by making the entrepreneur a central figure in climate policy, and, by extension, environmentalism.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.