Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The Green New Deal is a refining of neoliberalism’s power using the façade of grassroots and leftist rhetoric to garner an ascetic of radicalism.

Alexander M. Stoner, 04 Jun 2020, (“Critical Reflections on America’s Green New Deal: Capital, Labor, and the Dynamics of Contemporary Social Change”, https://doi.org/10.1080/10455752.2020.1775860) #Gay Frog

Aside from denial, the more rational options available to confront GCC (e.g. cutting emissions through renewables, financial tax and/or getting rid of subsidies for fossil fuel companies) were explicitly stated or implied in the House Resolution for Green New Deal (GND hereafter), submitted by Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez 7 February 2019.2 The GND illustrates the entry of climate change politics into the U.S. political mainstream and represents the most comprehensive attempt to confront related issues within this domain to date. The House Resolution seized upon the urgency of the twin economic and ecological crisis. Its action plan emphasized the importance of incorporating both indigenous peoples and deindustrialized communities. Of concern for the purpose of this paper is the twin crisis of labor and the environment, which I shall return to elaborate on below. Although the measure died in the Senate the following month, its issues promise to live on, and therefore warrant further examination. The GND had three main goals: (1) achieve net-zero emissions through a fair and just transition for communities and workers; (2) create jobs; (3) invest in sustainable infrastructure and industry. Its action plan included public investment for the public good, including public banks and other public financing. The language of the GND harkens back to the 1930s moment, albeit with a 21st century ecological imperative, implying that a return to the 1930s moment, or at least the approach to social problems that prevailed during this time, is desirable and possible. But is this the case? The 1930s New Deal administration put an end to the U.S. tradition of federal minimalism, and its policies were necessary to save the U.S. from the destructive effects of finance capitalism (Dahms 2000). The changing relations between large investment banks and the federal government in turn, enabled the reconfiguration of business-labor-government relations that took hold following WWII. The post-WWII configuration of business-labor-government relations facilitated the economic boom associated with capitalism’s so-called “golden age”—a “productivist” approach to development later criticized by U.S. environmentalists. With the development of Keynesian state planning and economic coordination, the U.S. was able to overcome the decline in industrial output that beset the 1930s. The shift toward Keynesianism allowed capital to institutionalize a variety of productivity deals that linked increasing wages and profits to increasing productivity. Technological change geared toward steady productivity growth was fostered by collective bargaining and industrial union contracts as well as tax and investment policies of the state. Workers’ struggles for less work and more pay could be funded with increased investment and increasing productivity. What appeared to be a potentially destabilizing political atmosphere soon turned into a corporate endorsement of Keynesianism and conservative power realignment, as labor’s support of the New Deal administration’s social democratic affinities gradually inverted from 1945 to 1980 (Stoner and Melathopolous 2015). The tremendous advancements in productivity and related forms of accumulated knowledge that fueled the post-WWII approach to economic development in the U.S. accelerated environmental degradation and facilitated the growth of contemporary environmentalism. New environmental needs and desires emerged based on the growing recognition that a productivist industrial society is not adequate to the well-being of the natural environment. As the post-WWII form of “economic growth” expanded, environmental critics questioned its necessity. The targets of environmental discontents during the 1960s—namely, technology and affluence counter-positioned against finitude (e.g. “limits to growth”)—reflected this problematic. However, much like the labor unrest of the 1930s, the social crisis of the 1960s, including the crisis associated with the rise of contemporary environmentalism, was readily stabilized. By 1970 environmentalist concerns in the U.S. had become integrated into the system it sought to oppose (Stoner and Melathopolous 2015). Environmental discontents merged with the administrative state or became managed via class action lawsuits; social order was maintained while the underlying destructive processes continued. As the end of the 20th century unfolded, the integration of environmentalism paralleled the shift toward neoliberal capitalism—illustrated, for example, by the shift away from previous criticisms of “limits to growth,” which prevailed during the peak of monopoly capitalism, and toward a form of market environmentalism, according to which market mechanisms provide the best means of protecting the environment. The premise of market environmentalism—the autonomous eco-consumer—perniciously reflects competitive, individualistic value systems, i.e. the absence of social solidarity. At present, it is not clear how the social norms of cooperation and solidarity necessary for effective international GCC mitigation strategies might emerge as an effective counterweight to the cutthroat individualism characteristic of U.S. capitalism. While those on the Right may suffer from “structural amnesia,”3 without seriously confronting the underlying dynamics driving social change, some environmental advocates, including supporters of the GND, risk downplaying the transformations of capitalism, especially the impact these changes had on culture, politics, and identity formation.4 Such historical distortions problematically preclude insight into the limitations and possibilities of related contemporary initiatives. One must bear in mind that the U.S. House Resolution may not reflect the politics or ideologies behind it. It is also important to consider how the GND is mediated by politics itself. While such a consideration is beyond the scope of this paper, it is likely that the House Resolution is authored through comprmise and strategic thinking rather than a straightforward expression of what proponents at the grassroots want. The GND, as an ideological expression, reflects this compromise. Within the wider historical context of the GND, grassroots politics has arguably pulled the federal-level conversation to the left.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.