“Green jobs” offered by GND have inherently capitalist ideals which prioritize economic development and productivity.
Hoffmann & Paulsen ‘20 [a Department of Socioeconomics, Vienna University of Economics and Business, Vienna, Austria] “Resolving the ‘jobs-environment-dilemma’? The case for critiques of work in sustainability research, Environmental Sociology”, 6:4, 343-354, DOI: 10.1080/23251042.2020.1790718 (https://www.tandfonline.com/doi/full/10.1080/23251042.2020.1790718) // marlborough-am//
However, problem definitions and proposed ways forward are contested.Approaches under the notions of ‘sustainable work’, ‘decent work’, or ‘green jobs’, lately often as part of a ‘Green New Deal’, mostly follow the political agenda of continued economic growth, industrial development, and (labour) market expansion worldwide, under the guiding principles of development and the ‘green economy’ (ILO Citation2012, ILO Citation2015; UNDP Citation2015; UNEP Citation2008). These notions regard work and rising labour productivity as ends in themselves. They usually focus on ‘green jobs’ in certain sectors and their ‘green growth’ prospects, while taking the compatibility of sustainability, job creation, and technologically advanced industrial growth economies for granted (Bowen Citation2012).Other (yet related) approaches are normatively motivated in a more subtle manner. Two cases in point are environmental labour studies and the debate on ‘Just Transition’. Environmental labour studies focus on work and environment from the perspective of labour organisations and their relation to ‘nature’ also under the global green economy agenda, but partly with a critical stance towards the latter (e.g., Barca Citation2019; Barth, Jochum, and Littig Citation2016; Hyde and Vachon Citation2019; Lundström, Räthzel, and Uzzell Citation2015; Räthzel and Uzzell Citation2013; Rosemberg Citation2010; Stevis, Uzzell, and Räthzel Citation2018). Through their common ideological grounding in Marxist theory – disregarding Marx’ famous discussion of the ‘realm of freedom’ beyond labour and the necessity to shorten the working-day – work is taken for granted in the Marxist notion of work as an ‘eternal natural necessity’ and as something inherently good to be secured and expanded (an interpretation predominating in the Marxist and socialist tradition).Footnote3 Accordingly, it needs to be reconciled with ecological concerns, but not be questioned as a potential part of the problem. The debates on ‘Just Transition’ for example are selective about who deserves justice and on what grounds, and the priority lies clearly with the industries and workers immediately affected (Hyde and Vachon Citation2019). Contributions like these also underrate the scale of ecological challenges by focusing on certain ‘green’ sectors and too often disregarding, or disproportionately downplaying, the sectors that cannot be ‘greened’ and need to be reduced or discontinued entirely (ILO Citation2012).