Cap unsustainable – targets global south and decreases wage labor
Bader & Bieri 23 – [Christoph Bader and Sabin Bieri, both Drs., Centre for Development and Environment (CDE), University of Bern, Switzerland, “Transitioning to Reduced Inequalities: ‘A World Drifting Apart: Challenges and Possibilities of Transitioning to a More Equitable Planet,’” Transitioning to Sustainables Series, vol 10, MDPI, 2/9/23, doi:10.3390/books978-3-03921-161-6] /jsam
Globalization unfolds on the basis of a specific institutional architecture that systematically creates opportunities for economic expansion, thereby transgressing political borders. Expanding global supply chains have been a major spur to economic growth in emerging economies, enabling them to narrow the income gap to advanced economies (see, e.g., chapter by Palan et al.). However, the same architecture simultaneously creates unequal terms for participation in global markets. Globalization has therefore not paid off for low-income countries. On the contrary, it appears that structural inequalities have been reinforced, and the gap between the Global North and the Global South has grown not least due to reforms during the Washington consensus and its structural adjustment programs (Hickel 2017). In the global South, this is illustrated by increasing land inequality. This is a direct impact of neoliberal globalization, producing particularly devastating effects on people’s resilience, especially in rural areas and in view of unpredictable pressure on resources due to the consequences of climate change (Wegerif and Guereña 2020). The conventional wisdom that attributes widening inequalities to globalization and technological change leaves out some of the largest and most significant economic and political disruptions that are constitutive of the globalizing forces. One of the biggest shifts since the 1980s is the systematic undermining of countervailing powers that offset the influence of large corporations, global financial markets, and the wealthy elite. Contrary to the rhetoric, it is not the free market that creates objectively fair outcomes—not for people, let alone for the environment. Markets depend on rules, and rules come out of legislator bodies, executive agencies, and courts (Reich 2019). Among potential countervailing powers are labor unions, state and local banks, cooperatives, small retail chains, and local communities (Rajan 2019). With shrinking checks and balances, we find ourselves in an unhinged system that produces structural inequalities. Robert Reich (2020) describes this as the vicious cycles in which big money, which emanates from large corporations, global financial markets, and the wealthy determine the rules of the economic and social game. Even more so, Nobel laureate Angus Deaton warns about the disruptive effects on liberal democracies if the wealthy are allowed to influence political outcomes to a degree that gives systematic preference to their particular interests (Deaton 2013). The weakening redistributive role of the state is an example of these dynamics. In OECD economies, taxes and transfers typically maintain disposable income inequality at one-fifth to one-quarter lower than typical market-income inequality. In recent years, the role of fiscal redistribution in offsetting the rise in market income inequality has shrunk because of the reduced progressivity of personal income taxes; lower taxes on capital, including those on inheritance and corporations; and tightening of public on social programs, including health and education programs in the wake of widely rolled-out austerity policies, such as those that were implemented after the 2007 financial crisis (Canterbery 2015). A second element that much of the inequality-related research has increasingly focused on is (skill-biased) technological change as a key driver of the rise in inequality during the last few decades. The rapid increase in digital technologies has been received with much hope for the broader, more inclusive participation of so far by-passed population segments in these developments and the opportunities that they offer access to. Digital technologies have indeed substantially transformed markets, including the way we work and do business. However, against initial hopes, the gains of these technological advancements have the tendency to be shared highly unequally, something that is largely due to the disadvantage of workers and the populations in the global South more generally. The characteristics of digital goods play well into the logic of a globalized economy, where they enjoy huge advantages due to their replicability, their weightlessness, and their non-rival, synchronized nature (Quah 2003). On the other hand, these new technologies require substantial investments, thus favoring capital and leading to shrinking income shares from wage labor (ILO 2019). Moreover, the skill set needed to operate and manage digital tools effectively requires educational initiatives, particularly in low-income countries. The results of these programs only pay off after years of investments—investments that are all too often far from realistic for the budgets of low-income economies. The current COVID-19 pandemic seems to amplify these trends of widening technology gaps between the global regions (Ferreira et al. 2021; Martínez et al. 2021). While the overall picture confirms the continuous exacerbation of inequality, the trajectories are different depending on a countries policies. In other words: policies matter (Piketty et al. 2020). However, much of what we have seen from governments so far is conventional sectoral politics, little of which has been linked to the pertinent question of sustainability.