UBI is a part of a series of Marxist reforms that will solve ecological disaster and increase productivity.
Duffy 19 [Simon Duffy, Simon has a doctorate in moral philosophy and writes on the welfare state, citizenship, social justice and inclusion. Key publications include Unlocking the Imagination (1996), Keys to Citizenship (2003) Women at the Centre (2011) A Fair Income (2011) Peer Power (2012) and The Unmaking of Man (2013). The Marxist Case for Basic Income ,May 7, 2019 MP]
What makes Mason’s Marxism different to these competing aristocratic, rational and revolutionary forms is his commitment to cooperation (which he calls peer to peer exchange) and his view that emerging technological change has put us on the cusp of a deeper social and economic changes that can move us beyond capitalism. Mason stresses the emergence of networks, cooperative systems, free public goods and the possibility of abundance as the real basis for replacing capitalism. His challenge is that the current economic system is stuck in a form of late capitalism, which is failing, and that future reform requires a complex transition away from neoliberalism and towards a postcapitalist world of high productivity and networked cooperation. Hence basic income is only one element of a reformed system; Mason proposes a series of economic reforms, and in particular taking complete control over energy production, in order to rapidly move the planet onto a sustainable path to a world where we are able to enjoy increasing amounts of free time. In a sense Mason is trying to combine two different traditions on the Left. On the one hand, mutualism, which is not really a Marxist tradition, but which values equality, cooperation and community as the natural forms of social justice. On the other hand there is the historical-materialist Marxist tradition which is strongly committed to the idea that social developments are underpinned by the form of productive life that sustain itself, but which will then evolve around the emergence of new technologies. Mason is arguing that mutualism is the essence of postcapitalism, but that it can only really emerge and thrive if we manage the complex transition away from the current system towards a new model which will require radically different systems of democratic control, financing and management. There is so much going on in Mason’s book that it is impossible to make any simple judgements about it. It is an exciting vision of the future, and also an education in the fractured world of Marxist theory. Even if you are not a convinced Marxist it is hard to resist his analysis of the global economic, political and environment crisis we face today. It is exciting and encouraging to see that basic income, while no panacea, may not only help us move our world away from ecological disaster, but could also help create the productivity gains that will be essential to move the whole human population out of poverty and into a world of equal citizenship. Certainly, as UBI Lab Sheffield itself demonstrates, there are very many of us who are willing to use our free time, despite the costs of our precarity, to advance social justice and to seek a shift in power towards citizens and to our local communities. So we are ourselves living proof of the existence of networked individuals who are willing to come together to think and act, not because we are being paid, but because we think the work is important.