No ocean acidification impact and CO2 increases ocean bio-d
Goklany, 15—independent scholar and author, member of the US delegation that established the IPCC and helped develop its First Assessment Report, he subsequently served as a US delegate to the IPCC, and an IPCC reviewer, he is a member of the GWPF’s Academic Advisory Council (Indur, “CARBON DIOXIDE: The good news”, http://www.thegwpf.org/content/uploads/2015/10/benefits1.pdf, dml)
Increasing carbon dioxide levels in the atmosphere clearly increase the growth rate of land plants, other things being equal. Is the same true for marine photosynthesisers such as algae, phytoplankton and symbiotic zooxanthellae in corals? Carbon dioxide dissolves in seawater and there is good evidence that this causes enhanced growth rates in many taxa. This is despite the fact that dissolved carbon dioxide forms bicarbonate ions, which slightly decrease the pH of the water, leading to what is often inaccurately called ‘ocean acidification’. There is no likelihood of the ocean’s average pH getting anywhere near as low as 7 because of elevated carbon dioxide concentrations during the next three centuries. Ocean pH currently averages about 8 and is forecast to fall by 0.2 pH units or so during the present century. This change is considerably smaller than the difference in pH between different parts of the ocean, different days in the same part of the ocean, and even different times of day in coral reef lagoons. An examination of upper-ocean pH for a wide variety of ecosystems ranging from polar to tropical, open-ocean to coastal, kelp forest to coral reefs, indicates that variations in month-long pH spanned a range of 0.024 –1.430 pH units, and found that many organisms ‘are already experiencing pH regimes that are not predicted until 2100.’93 In other words, the projected change in pH is much smaller than the noise in its natural variation. So it is highly speculative that this small long-term trend will bring problems for marine life that are greater than the benefits of extra carbon dioxide for photosynthetic marine organisms and hence the whole marine biosphere.
Here follow some examples of studies finding positive or neutral impacts of lower pH on different groups of marine photosynthesisers:
Cocolithophores Iglesias-Rodriguez et al. found evidence that ‘calcification and net primary production in the coccolithophore species Emiliania huxleyi are significantly increased by high carbon dioxide partial pressures’ in the laboratory while ‘field evidence from the deep ocean is consistent with these laboratory conclusions, indicating that over the past 220 years there has been a 40% increase in average coccolith mass’.94 Coccolithophores are among the most abundant phytoplankton in the oceans. Notably, Duarte et al. classify the evidence for a decline of calcifiers due to ocean acidification for this century as weak.95
Diatoms In diatoms, ‘no significant change in the yield was found between the low and high carbon dioxide levels’ and ‘increased dissolved carbon dioxide concentration did not affect the mean cell size and cell volume of Phaeodactylum tricornutum’.96 Foraminifera Vogel and Uthicke found that ‘the species investigated were still able to build up their calcite skeletons in carbon dioxide conditions predicted for the year 2100 and beyond’, and ‘contrary to expectations, M. vertebralis showed significantly increased growth rates in elevated carbon dioxide’.97
Marine algae and other marine plants In marine algae, many studies find that enhanced carbon dioxide results in faster growth. In other marine plants such as eelgrasses, Palacios and Zimmermann concluded that ‘ocean acidification will stimulate seagrass biomass and productivity, leading to more favorable habitat and conditions for associated invertebrate and fish species’.98 Indeed, according to Hendriks et al, the carbon dioxide fertilisation effect might reverse acidification: ‘sea-grass photosynthetic rates may increase by 50% with increased carbon dioxide, which may deplete the carbon dioxide pool, maintaining an elevated pH that may protect associated calcifying organisms from the impacts of ocean acidification’,99 at least in their vicinity.
Thus for many primary producers in the ocean, increased levels of dissolved carbon dioxide will stimulate ecosystem productivity with positive implications for the food chain. Studies suggest that this effect will probably outweigh any drawbacks from slightly lower pH.
Could the same be true for corals? Corals build reefs by calcification, depositing calcium carbonate in their skeletons. This process is energetically costly and the energy cost increases at lower pH. However, the energy is supplied by symbiotic zooxanthellae in the corals, which photosynthesise.100 Thus the limiting factor on coral growth may be biological rather than chemical. Muscatine et al. conclude that ‘symbiotic algae may control calcification by. . . modification of physico-chemical parameters within the coral polyps’.101 This could explain why the growth rate of coral reefs shows no signs of declining as predicted. As Kleypas et al. argue with respect to benthic corals, ‘[t]he drawdown of total dissolved inorganic carbon due to photosynthesis and calcification of reef communities can exceed the drawdown of total alkalinity due to calcification of corals and calcifying algae, leading to a net increase in aragonite saturation state’.102
The general finding that calcifier organisms do not deposit less calcium when carbon dioxide concentrations increase is borne out by an experimental study by Findlay et al. using three molluscs, one barnacle and a brittle star. They write that ‘contrary to popular predictions, the deposition of calcium carbonate can be maintained or even increased in acidified seawater’.103 Similarly, a ‘field growth experiment revealed seven times higher growth and calcification rates of [blue mussel Mytilus edulis] at a high carbon dioxide inner fjord field station . . .in comparison to a low pCO2 outer fjord station. . . ’104
Recent laboratory experiments to investigate the variation in the coral calcification rate of the scleractinian coral Siderastrea siderea – an abundant reef-builder in the Caribbean Sea – with warming and changes in pH found that under a more-orless constant temperature of 28◦C, calcification rates increased as atmospheric carbon dioxide was increased from near-pre-industrial levels of 324 ppm to 447 ppm, remained relatively unchanged at the predicted end-of-century value of 604 ppm and then returned to near-pre-industrial rates at 2500 ppm.105 It also found that while holding the carbon dioxide level at 488 ppm, calcification rates increased as the temperature increased from 25◦C to 28◦C, but it declined by 80% when temperature was increased to 32◦C. These results suggest that rapid ocean warming will pose a threat to S. siderea in the longer term but that ocean acidification will be little or no threat for several centuries. Moreover, the experimentally determined calcification rates might have been adversely affected by the disruption to the coral due to the need to cut, transplant and prepare it for analysis. No less important is the fact that the changes in pH and temperature were imposed over a period of just a few months. In the real world such changes would occur over a century or more, which means some adaptation cannot be precluded, for example via symbiont shuffling.106
By far the largest peer-reviewed meta-analysis of the effect of ocean acidification upon marine life came to a strikingly unfashionable conclusion. Hendriks et al. studied the results of 372 experiments involving raised carbon dioxide levels on 44 species and found ‘limited experimental support’ for the theoretical predictions of negative impacts of ocean acidification. Marine organisms, they conclude, are ‘more resistant to ocean acidification than suggested by pessimistic predictions. . . ’, and thus this phenomenon ‘may not be the widespread problem conjured into the 21st century’.107