Both Democrats and Republicans support a UBI.
Pesantez, 20 [Gabrielle Pesantez, My name is Gaby and I’m a senior in Mather House studying History. My main interests and previous coursework have been in European and Latin American legal and imperial history. I chose the History concentration for its flexibility and incredible professors. Outside of the department, I study French and Italian and serve on the Board of the Harvard Undergraduate Women in Law Association and Harvard Latina Empowerment & Development Conference. I have previously worked as a Research Assistant at the Center for European Studies and have written for the Harvard Undergraduate Law Review, Harvard Crimson, Harvard College Economics Review, and Harvard College History Review. I am currently an intern for the U.S. Foreign Service, where I’ve gotten to use my academic knowledge of European history and the legal foundations of the European Union to work on political and economic issues at the Department of State’s E.U. Office. , Universal Basic Income: A Bipartisan Solution to COVID’s Economic Turmoil, Harvard Economics Review, August 3, 2020.]
A UBI clearly has the potential to introduce positive change in the realm of Americans’ individual and overall economic security. Jack Dorsey, C.E.O. of Twitter, recently 3 million dollars to help fund U.S. Mayors for Universal Basic Income pilot programs in 15 cities. These pilot programs test the tangible impacts of UBI payments within local communities, measuring UBI’s potential as an economic empowerment mechanism. The Mayors for Universal Basic Income coalition is led by Mayor Michael Tubbs of Stockton, who a local UBI pilot program in his community in late 2018. Recent findings from the Stockton pilot program that 40 percent of tracked monthly spending went to purchasing food, with participants investing their UBI funds in nutritious, high-quality food for their families. Beyond alleviating food insecurity, the Stockton UBI allowed participants to and invest newfound time or money into their individualized, immediate needs. Mayor Tubbs, that many Republican-leaning states “have the highest rates of economic insecurity and poverty [in the country,]” is confident that both parties will see value in supporting UBI proposals. The one point of contention standing in the way of this potentially transformative entitlement ultimately lies in the method of financing the UBI. Fortunately, Democratic and Republican politicians might be accepting of a plan like Yang’s: the VAT can serve as a form of progressive taxation when used to fund the UBI and somewhat similar taxes have previously been by Republican Senators Ted Cruz and Rand Paul, along with former House Speaker Paul Ryan. Though critics of the VAT might argue that the tax is regressive, as lower-income consumers spend a greater proportion of their income purchasing goods compared to their higher-income counterparts, proposals such as Yang’s account for these concerns. Yang’s plan that not all goods, namely groceries and clothing, would be subject to the VAT. According to the Yang campaign’s estimates, a consumer would have to at least 120,000 dollars worth of taxable goods before having spent a sum equivalent to their UBI payment. In a time of immense political polarization, when Democrat-backed progressive forms of taxation are unlikely to win approval by the, a UBI promises both parties a chance to close the partisan divides while helping struggling Americans in dire times. Results from pilot programs and current UBI experimentation have already begun to the immense personal value, comfort, and stability that a UBI can offer. Our lack of a substantial social safety net is clear. Social distancing requirements continue to on the assistance that normally-operational social, health, and legal service providers can offer to vulnerable individuals. Right now, direct cash assistance is more important than ever, but temporary stimulus payments should not be the end of this debate. Amidst so much uncertainty, a UBI offers an opportunity for genuine collaboration in the movement to reimagine and revitalize social security. The U.S. should seize the opportunity to permanently plug the holes in the social safety net, finally offering its citizens a long-awaited, substantive form of economic empowerment