ATC modernization solves aviation emissions—fuel and contrails.
Spinardi 15—Senior Lecturer at the University of Edinburgh's School of Engineering (Graham. “Up in the Air: Barriers to Greener Air Traffic Control and Infrastructure Lock-in in a Complex Socio-Technical System.” Energy Research & Social Science, vol. 6, Mar. 2015, https://doi.org/10.1016/j.erss.2014.11.006)
Aviation contributes to climate change by increasing levels of greenhouse gases such as carbon dioxide, ozone and water vapour, and by stimulating the creation of cirrus cloud around ‘contrails’ (condensation trails) that reflect more energy back to the earth than they reflect away from the earth. Total ‘radiative forcing’ – simply put, atmospheric warming – due to aviation is thought to be about three times that due to aircraft carbon dioxide emissions alone [60, p. 18]. Using biofuels (assuming that these can be sourced in a way that is both environmentally and economically desirable) would thus only be a partial solution.
More efficient ATC offers a ‘win-win’ outcome, with both environmental and economic benefits. For example, a 2000 report on aviation and the environment by the US Government Accounting Office (GAO) noted that:
Operational improvements in such areas as communications, navigation, surveillance, and air traffic management could also lead to reductions in aircraft emissions. … improvements in air traffic management worldwide could reduce the annual consumption of aircraft fuel by 6 to 12 percent over the next 20 years [26, p. 22].
The potential environmental benefits lie in two areas. First, better ATC could make air travel more fuel-efficient. The ideal flight path for an aircraft would be for it to be able to operate as if there were no other aircraft around, and so no potential conflicts that would force it to take a sub-optimum flight path. An optimum flight path, in terms of fuel efficiency, would not only take the shortest route, and involve no ‘stacking’ while waiting for a landing slot, but it would also fly at the optimum (high) altitude for most of the journey, with a continuous ‘cruise climb’ after take-off, and land following a continuous ‘idle thrust’ descent. In particular, enabling aircraft to utilise idle thrust descents, with low engine power, is a key challenge for ATC because of the complexity and time pressure of many different types of aircraft converging on a limited landing space at an airport. ATC automation enables trajectories to be predicted, and adjustments made, further from the airport so that the final descent can be smooth and energy efficient.
Second, greater ATC automation could enable aircraft to avoid areas most likely to produce contrails, thus minimising the radiative forcing resulting from cloud formation, although there would be trade-offs involved in not flying the most direct routes [64]. Aviation-induced cirrus cloud formation has a potentially large impact on radiative forcing that cannot be ameliorated by the use of biofuels or improved aircraft efficiency [72, p. 743]. Sophisticated ATC might also enable aircraft to fly below contrail-prone altitudes although again there would be a trade-off with fuel-efficiency, and maybe objections on grounds of comfort and safety.