Free beta access. 50 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

China’s defensive realist. Every misdeed is committed on a larger scale by the US.

Steve Chan 9-6-2021. College Professor of Distinction and Chair of the Political Science Department at the University of Colorado. "Challenging the liberal order: the US hegemon as a revisionist power". International Affairs, Volume 97, Issue 5, September 2021, Pages 1335–1352. https://academic.oup.com/ia/article/97/5/1335/6363965. Pen-DL

What about Chinese misconduct? Various objections can be raised to the conclusion just stated. For example, one may argue that the United States has adhered to the norm of territorial integrity by withdrawing from countries that it had invaded, and that it has opposed secession movements, whereas China has not adhered to this norm, claiming a large portion of the South China Sea and pursuing territorial disputes with Japan and India. However, during its years of ascendancy the United States acquired vast amounts of territory by defeating Mexico and Spain (equivalent to all or parts of today's Arizona, California, Colorado, Nevada, New Mexico, Utah and Wyoming, in addition to Guam, Puerto Rico and the Philippines), and no scholar to my knowledge has considered the United States to be revisionist on account of this conduct. Germany's historical territorial acquisitions appear puny by comparison. Whether the United States opposes secession depends on one's perspective. Was Saigon attempting to secede from Vietnam, and Taiwan from China? Washington surely enabled the breakup of the former Yugoslavia. It also supported Panama's secession from Colombia with the aim of building a canal there. China withdrew its troops from North Korea after the 1953 armistice, but US troops are still in South Korea. China has the world's largest number of land borders with other countries. It has settled nearly all of them, usually on terms favourable to its smaller neighbours.55 Its boundary disputes with India and Nepal are the sole exceptions. It does have maritime disputes with several countries, and it has rejected the Permanent Court of Arbitration's jurisdiction in its dispute with Manila in the South China Sea. Other signatories of UNCLOS have also invoked this provision to be exempted from dispute settlement by an international tribunal. But the United States has not even signed this convention. It has refused to accept the International Court of Justice's ruling that it had violated international law when it mined Nicaragua's ports, and it also challenged the freedom of navigation when ‘quarantining’ Cuba in 1962. Quoting Singapore's former ambassador to the United Nations, Kishore Mahbubani, that ‘China is the only great power today that has not fired a single bullet across its borders in 30 years [as of 2010]’, David Kang notes that ‘by contrast, even under the peaceful American presidency of Barack Obama, the United States dropped 26,000 bombs on seven countries in 2016’.56 China has also been accused of undertaking predatory trade policies. Yet Daniel Drezner reports that ‘China's compliance with adverse WTO rulings was better than that of either the United States or the European Union’, and concludes that ‘China, far from acting like a spoiler, acted primarily as a responsible stakeholder to reinforce the preexisting rules of the global economic game’.57 By contrast, Broz and colleagues note that the United States has made more frequent use of WTO exceptions to protect domestic industries from foreign competition than any other nation … Foreign nations have initiated more complaints at the WTO against the US for violating trade-exception rules than against any other nation or region, including the European Union.58 These remarks do not excuse Beijing's malpractices, but do put them in a comparative light. What about election meddling? Washington has alleged Russian interference in its 2016 presidential election, and Chinese and Iranian interference as well in its 2020 election. The United States has, however, meddled in other countries' elections far more frequently and flagrantly, dating back at least to its efforts to prevent a communist victory in Italy's 1948 election.59 It was also complicit in military coups or engaged in outright invasions that overthrew foreign governments (e.g. in Chile, Grenada, Guatemala, Iran, South Vietnam and, unsuccessfully, Cuba). It has even physically seized another country's leader (Panama's Manuel Noriega) and assassinated a foreign official in a third country (Iran's General Qasem Soleimani in Baghdad). By contrast, China has not been associated with such actions or the assassination of other countries' nuclear scientists.60 Again, there should be some consideration of frequency and magnitude in evaluating any country's conduct or misconduct. Washington has accused China of cyber espionage and has lobbied other countries to ban Huawei from their 5G infrastructure on the grounds that this Chinese telecommunications company may gain access to sensitive information and be required to turn it over to the Chinese government. The irony is not lost on Germany's economics minister Peter Altmaier, who remarked that it was the United States that surreptitiously taped Angela Merkel's telephone conversations in 2015, and that ‘the US also requires its companies to provide certain information needed to fight terrorism’.61 Edward Snowden disclosed mass surveillance undertaken by the National Security Agency with the cooperation of European governments and US telecommunications companies. Public media have reported the United States planting listening devices on a Boeing aircraft sold for use by China's president.62 Media reports have also pointed to the United States and Israel using a computer virus (Stuxnet) to damage Iran's nuclear programme. In short, ‘hacking’ and ‘cyber warfare’ are not being undertaken just by the Chinese. China's mistreatment of its domestic political dissidents and ethnic minorities can also give rise to scepticism about its foreign policy. A country that mistreats its own citizens is unlikely to treat foreigners better. The irony here is that Sino-American relations were much more cordial and cooperative during the Nixon, Ford and Carter years when China had an even more authoritarian government than it does today. Although one should not condone any violation of human rights or political repression, a degree of introspection and a comparative perspective would again be welcome. Recent protests in Hong Kong occurred around the time of mass demonstrations in Bolivia, Chile, Colombia, Ecuador, France, Iran, Iraq, Lebanon and the United States (‘Black Lives Matter’). In January 2021, there were also mass protests in the Netherlands (over curfews imposed in response to the pandemic), India (over government subsidies for farmers), the United States (over alleged election irregularities) and Russia (by supporters of Alexei Navalny). Which countries have had more casualties and arrests as a result of police action? Many Americans were horrified by the spectacle of Trump's supporters storming the Capitol and called them ‘insurrectionists’; but many of them would also have seen scenes of rioters seizing and vandalizing Hong Kong's Legislative Council, and few would use the same label to describe those demanding Hong Kong's independence. These episodes point to people's asymmetric access to information, and their application of seemingly different standards of evaluation. One usually does not hear much reference to the plight of Palestinians or Native Americans in judging whether Israel or the United States is or was ‘revisionist’.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.