Unemployment benefits do not shrink the labor force, they maintain it.
Economic Policy Institute 10 [Economic Policy Institute is an independent, nonprofit think tank that researches the impact of economic trends and policies on working people in the United States. EPI’s research helps policymakers, opinion leaders, advocates, journalists, and the public understand the bread-and-butter issues affecting ordinary Americans. “Extending unemployment insurance is the fiscally responsible thing to do,” May 28, 2010. https://www.epi.org/publication/extending_unemployment_insurance_is_the_fiscally_responsible_thing_to_/]
The Labor Department’s Rothstein argued that the current size of the jobs shortage made a much stronger case for extended unemployment insurance, to support both the jobless and the overall economy. “I don’t think there’s anybody advocating allowing the unemployed to receive 99 weeks of benefits in normal times,” he said. “But if there really are no jobs, that cost (of providing unemployment insurance) goes away.”
The so-called cost Rothstein referred to was not the actual cost of unemployment benefits but what critics have often argued is a disincentive cost, which effectively discourages unemployed workers from looking for jobs. Contrary to that argument, he stressed that even in more normal economic times, research has found only a slim disincentive effect. In times of severe jobs crisis, there is good reason to think that extending unemployment insurance actually increases job search efforts, since in order to qualify for benefits, a person must be actively looking for a job. “The shortage of job searching is not the problem,” he said. “The problem is a shortage of jobs.”
Chetty explained how recent evidence in the economic literature shows that the work disincentive effects of unemployment insurance are much smaller than what has sometimes been implied by previous estimates. He said that most of the increase in unemployment duration due to unemployment insurance is not a negative effect generated by distorted work incentives, but the benefit that having cash-in-hand provides in the form of reduced chaos in the lives of cash-strapped families. He argued that even in normal times, the benefits of UI are now understood to be large relative to the work disincentive costs. Furthermore, the benefits of UI are likely to be larger in this deep, long downturn, and work disincentive effects are likely to be smaller, so weighing costs against benefits, extending benefits further in the current economy would significantly increase economic welfare.
Till von Wachter, associate professor of economics at Columbia University, offered more evidence that providing unemployment insurance helps keep jobless workers in the labor force and improving the likelihood of them returning to work once the job market improves. “A high fraction of the unemployed who lose their benefits will end up out of the labor force,” he said noting that many of these discouraged workers apply for permanent Social Security disability. Once on disability, very few workers re-enter the labor force. Therefore, providing UI can be fiscally responsible, argued von Wachter.